Live data from Hacker News

The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

restofworld.org

21–30 of 45 posts

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#21
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

TikTok is Chinese. When someone says subcontinent they usually mean the India and its neighbours Pakistan, Nepal, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka.

And when they say Indochina, they mean neither India nor China.

Xi Jinping would like to have a word with you.

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#22

Not saying that what they did is not commendable (in my mind even if you get more than 10 users, your app/site is already great), but ultimately it was a copy. There was nothing original as such. Just an app with Indianised version of a bird sound won't work in the long haul right ? Also their user base gain was because of controversies, you bring controversial public, they're gonna want that sort of environment. One…

So many (perhaps most) successful apps and platforms are copies. It's not an argument for or against success.

Even Airplane was a copy!

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#23
Why every new social media clone looks the same?

I don't know much about large scale projects, but wouldn't hosting videos become a huge cost in a project like this? Many social medias didn't have video support until they were huge. In fact, I think Plurk still doesn't support it, even though it has existed for 16 years.

But the other day I learned about this "TikTok" thing that is video-centric, and that there is a clone called Kwai, which is also video-centric, and that everyone seems to want a platform to share videos for some reason.

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#24

Why every new social media clone looks the same? I don't know much about large scale projects, but wouldn't hosting videos become a huge cost in a project like this? Many social medias didn't have video support until they were huge. In fact, I think Plurk still doesn't support it, even though it has existed for 16 years. But the other day I learned about this "TikTok" thing that is video-centric, and that there is a…

For an average person, video is easier to consume. That means it's easier to create a loop resulting in much better engagement

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#25

Twitter dies as soon as free money stops. Many internet companies are zombies or even worse

Surely twitter's value isn't in its revenue.... you can make a lot more money openly manipulating public opinion in a socially acceptable manner. See: why rich people buy newspapers.

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#26

People are out of ideas. Twitter but for India. Twitter but not owned Elon Musk. Twitter but integrated with substack. Twitter but federated. Twitter but decentralized. Will any of these do better? Possibly the last two, if someone builts an innovative user experience on top of them.

What’s the twitter that’s not owned by musk? Because I’m surprised there isn’t a single twitter clone alternative.

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#27

People are out of ideas. Twitter but for India. Twitter but not owned Elon Musk. Twitter but integrated with substack. Twitter but federated. Twitter but decentralized. Will any of these do better? Possibly the last two, if someone builts an innovative user experience on top of them.

What’s the twitter that’s not owned by musk? Because I’m surprised there isn’t a single twitter clone alternative.

Truth social. It's not Musk but you know who else it is.

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#28

People are out of ideas. Twitter but for India. Twitter but not owned Elon Musk. Twitter but integrated with substack. Twitter but federated. Twitter but decentralized. Will any of these do better? Possibly the last two, if someone builts an innovative user experience on top of them.

What’s the twitter that’s not owned by musk? Because I’m surprised there isn’t a single twitter clone alternative.

BlueSky? Threads by Mark Zuckerberg?

Re: The rise and fall of Koo, India’s once-thriving Twitter alternative

#29

Social media in subcontinent is really hard since the ARPU is really low compared to the cost required to sustain that scale. All the existing one prevail because most of their revenue comes from US + EU to balance out additional cost in resources.

Roughly what proportion of the ARPU on social media comes from expat Indians/ OCIs vs Indian-resident users? Ditto for Pakistan and Bangladesh?
Post reply on HN