Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 74 posts

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#51
gave up on Adobe years ago. (abhor subscriptions)

Photoimpact was my fave for a long time, now mainly using affinity designer / photo, photopea and for quick fixes there are dozens of online ai-like things to do most of what needs getting done.

recently found a powertoys addon that lets me resize image using windows context menu / right click -> resize pictures.. no program to load / open.

Corel videostudio and davinci resolve, own it - no subscription needed.

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#52
I just cancelled my Adobe subscription after trying to cancel for more than 6 months, so many dark patterns that caused my wife to sign in for a renew when she didn't want. To actually cancel you have to say you want to actually cancel in 3-4 different screens, where there's always an option to renew instead for a whole year that you cannot cancel.

I am never going to pay for Adobe while this practices continue.

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#53
post #39

My free stack, 2024 edition: Fedora Linux Sway spin, Inkscape, GNU Image Manipulation Program, KdenLive, Natron, Blender, FreeCAD, KiCAD, OpenSCAD, Orca slicer, IceCat, Zulip, LibreOffice, and a flock of CLI tools

2024 and Gimp remains horrible (as it has always been). It’s cool it brings value to you and others but Photoshop replacement it is not.

With enough disgruntled ex-Adobe users looking for something new, you'd think GIMP would be improved or replaced by better free software.

I feel that people switching to another proprietary thing will just run into problems again in the future. It makes more sense to come up with a permanent solution.

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#54
I paid for the full Creative Cloud for years… Recently I switched to Affinity Designer and Affinity Publisher, which have both been fantastic replacements for Illustrator and InDesign respectively.

However, I kept a $10/month subscription to Lightroom & Photoshop, because I have an enormous Lightroom catalog. They have me over a barrel on Lightroom.

There is also no replacement for Adobe After Effects if it's part of your workflow. There's Fusion in the DaVinci Resolve suite, but it's much different.

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#55

Figma for all UX design. Affinity Photo for bitmap editing (which is vanishingly rare these days). Affinity Designer for a few vector operations and tools not supported by Figma. Affinity Publisher for print design (aka when I need to update my resume...). Instead of Adobe Stock, I use Pexels, or just generate a sufficiently generic image on ChatGPT. Instead of Adobe Fonts, I just stopped being a web developer, ha ha…

Don't forget about self-hosted web fonts! People forget this is even an option

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#56
post #39

My free stack, 2024 edition: Fedora Linux Sway spin, Inkscape, GNU Image Manipulation Program, KdenLive, Natron, Blender, FreeCAD, KiCAD, OpenSCAD, Orca slicer, IceCat, Zulip, LibreOffice, and a flock of CLI tools

2024 and Gimp remains horrible (as it has always been). It’s cool it brings value to you and others but Photoshop replacement it is not.

Depends what you need it for. I don't think it's bad but my use-cases are very simple.

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#57
post #39

My free stack, 2024 edition: Fedora Linux Sway spin, Inkscape, GNU Image Manipulation Program, KdenLive, Natron, Blender, FreeCAD, KiCAD, OpenSCAD, Orca slicer, IceCat, Zulip, LibreOffice, and a flock of CLI tools

2024 and Gimp remains horrible (as it has always been). It’s cool it brings value to you and others but Photoshop replacement it is not.

IMO many of its most glaring issues could be fixed by “simply” (I know it’s probably more involved in reality) swapping out bespoke widgets for standard GTK counterparts with more standard/commonly familiar behaviors.

The poster child for this is easily the layers palette. It looks like a scrolling list widget like you’d find on any major desktop OS released in the past 30 years but doesn’t behave like one, with oddities like inability to multi-select. Instead, the user is expected to learn GIMP-specific behaviors that aren’t useful in any other program. There’s not really a good reason for this, aside for familiarity for existing users and while that’s an important thing to consider I’m not sure it’s worth impeding retention of new users.

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#59
The bulk of my UI graphics and mockup work has been in Sketch for around a decade at this point, with the odd excursion into Pixelmator Pro or Affinity Photo for work more suited for raster graphics. For vector work I’ll occasionally use Affinity Designer when Sketch isn’t working quite the way I’d like for some reason or another.

Have tried Figma and it’s ok I guess, but leans too far into prototyping and collab for my own personal use, plus I don’t like how they keep your full fidelity original documents locked away in an proprietary document format (Sketch’s file format is open and publicly documented).

I have a Photoshop license but it’s used only for following art instruction videos (drawing, painting, etc) just to reduce friction, since that’s what the bulk of instructors are using and I don’t want to fuss with remapping keys and hunting down equivalent functionality mid-lesson. All “serious” work is done with other software.

Re: Ask HN: What alternatives to Adobe products are you switching to?

#60
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

2024 and Gimp remains horrible (as it has always been). It’s cool it brings value to you and others but Photoshop replacement it is not.

IMO many of its most glaring issues could be fixed by “simply” (I know it’s probably more involved in reality) swapping out bespoke widgets for standard GTK counterparts with more standard/commonly familiar behaviors. The poster child for this is easily the layers palette. It looks like a scrolling list widget like you’d find on any major desktop OS released in the past 30 years but doesn’t behave like one, with oddi…

IMHO the problems in the usability of the software go far deeper than simply switching the widgets.

This is not to shit on Gimp! It's a completely adequate package of various image processing algorithms.

However, this does not make it a replacement for Photoshop for a large segment of users.

I've been using Photoshop for 30 years and tried to use gimp for 25 years :D

Post reply on HN