Live data from Hacker News

Possible exposure of Earth to dense interstellar medium 2-3M years ago

nature.com

21–30 of 66 posts

Re: Possible exposure of Earth to dense interstellar medium 2-3M years ago

#21

Very interesting paper! Proposes (with lower bound of 1.3% chance) that the solar system may have passed through a local interstellar cloud, which would have caused the heliosphere to shrink to smaller than the orbit of the earth (0.22 au) some 2-3 mya. This may have affected the Earth's atmosphere and climate. Scroll down for some cool illustrations of a simulation showing how the heliosphere would have been tiny wi…

> This may have affected the Earth's atmosphere and climate.

Adding uncertainty to climate forecasting models. Can we detect or predict changes to the interstellar medium in our path through space and improve forecasts with that? Maybe we could at least put an upper bound on the magnitude of the effect.

Re: Possible exposure of Earth to dense interstellar medium 2-3M years ago

#23

Very interesting paper! Proposes (with lower bound of 1.3% chance) that the solar system may have passed through a local interstellar cloud, which would have caused the heliosphere to shrink to smaller than the orbit of the earth (0.22 au) some 2-3 mya. This may have affected the Earth's atmosphere and climate. Scroll down for some cool illustrations of a simulation showing how the heliosphere would have been tiny wi…

> This may have affected the Earth's atmosphere and climate. Adding uncertainty to climate forecasting models. Can we detect or predict changes to the interstellar medium in our path through space and improve forecasts with that? Maybe we could at least put an upper bound on the magnitude of the effect.

I learned this in the Cal Academy of Sciences the other day! Apparently we’re about halfway through a region of less interstellar activity.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_Bubble

Re: Possible exposure of Earth to dense interstellar medium 2-3M years ago

#25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Remember, modern humans appeared around 1.5-2M years ago, so this event, geologically speaking, happened shortly before the arrival of modern humans. Perhaps this event had something to do with us evolving.

Do you mean Homo Erectus or Homo Sapiens? Sapiens arrived around 300k years ago, according to Wikipedia. Erectus did indeed arrive around 2M years ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homo_erectus

Must be Erectus then. This must be the time the aliens placed the Monolith on Earth (and another one on the Moon that we haven't found yet because we're WAY behind on our Moon base program).

Re: Possible exposure of Earth to dense interstellar medium 2-3M years ago

#27

Why does this make me feel a little dirty and exposed ? Like, who knows what kinda alien DNA strands or spores are carried by the ISM?! I wonder if it would be possible to track biodiversity increases caused by the transit? Assuming there is biological material in the ISM, perhaps some of it made it into our biosphere! Very fun!

If you accept that we're all made of stardust, with a little sprinkling of ISM, it should make you feel more connected to the universe, not less. :)

Re: Possible exposure of Earth to dense interstellar medium 2-3M years ago

#28

are there no tree fossils from that era that can show one part of the year being different from the rest? I remember reading that dinosaur meteorite was discovered to have fallen in spring by those marks surely regular pattern of getting in-out of heliosphere be noticeable?

>surely regular pattern of getting in-out of heliosphere be noticeable?

Why do you say that? What would you look for?

Re: Possible exposure of Earth to dense interstellar medium 2-3M years ago

#29

Are we able to determine if other star systems have experienced the same type of encounter? (Not statistically, I mean detection or instrument based) I'm assuming it's either difficult or impossible to measure another star's heliopause. It would be fascinating to see the effects of a cold cloud interaction in "real" time!

>I'm assuming it's either difficult or impossible to measure another star's heliopause. It would be fascinating to see the effects of a cold cloud interaction in "real" time!

I'm pretty sure we observe it routinely. There are tons of beautiful pictures of stars blowing away Nursery nebula. This is the heliopause of those Stars interacting with dense interstellar medium

Re: Possible exposure of Earth to dense interstellar medium 2-3M years ago

#30

Anyone here read "Neck of the Giraffe"? He hypothesizes that cosmic ray bursts are responsible for mutational leaps in evolution. This seems similar.

I thought Ford Prefect was responsible for this one.

That entire sequence is so absurd.

Leaves are money!

Post reply on HN