Live data from Hacker News

Apple's On-Device and Server Foundation Models

machinelearning.apple.com

191–200 of 562 posts

Re: Apple's On-Device and Server Foundation Models

#193

For people interested in AI research, there's nothing new here. IMO they should do a better job of referencing existing papers and techniques. The way they wrote about "adaptors" can make it seem like it's something novel, but it's actually just re-iterating vanilla LoRA. It was enough to convince one of the top-voted HackerNews comments that this was a "huge development". Benchmarks are nice though.

"AI for the rest of us."

Re: Apple's On-Device and Server Foundation Models

#194

For people interested in AI research, there's nothing new here. IMO they should do a better job of referencing existing papers and techniques. The way they wrote about "adaptors" can make it seem like it's something novel, but it's actually just re-iterating vanilla LoRA. It was enough to convince one of the top-voted HackerNews comments that this was a "huge development". Benchmarks are nice though.

It's a huge development in terms of it being a consumer-ready, on-device LLM. And if Karpathy thinks so then I assume it's good enough for HN: https://x.com/karpathy/status/1800242310116262150

[flagged]

Re: Apple's On-Device and Server Foundation Models

#195

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's a huge development in terms of it being a consumer-ready, on-device LLM. And if Karpathy thinks so then I assume it's good enough for HN: https://x.com/karpathy/status/1800242310116262150

[flagged]

a) I would trust Karpathy over Elon given he doesn't have a competing product.

b) Apple only provides information to ChatGPT when the user consents to doing so and the information is only for that request i.e. it is not logged for future training.

Re: Apple's On-Device and Server Foundation Models

#196

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Was there anything about searching through our own photos using prompts? I thought this could be pretty amazing and still a natural way to find very specific photos in one’s own photo gallery.

Which is in turn just multimodal embedding Besides I could do "named person on a beach in August" and get the correct thing in photos on Android photos, so I don't get it. It's amazing for apple users if they didn't have it before. But from a tech stand point people could have had it for a while.

Photos has had this for a while with structured natural language queries, and this kind of prompt was part of the WWDC video.

Re: Apple's On-Device and Server Foundation Models

#197
post #84

Is it me or Apple is really moving fast? I don't think it is easy for a company of this size to concisely put a vision of AI in these short and crazy AI times. BTW, not an Apple fan but an Apple user.

Google had similar AI functionality on Pixels last year and Microsoft had like six AI CoPilot products before that. So I would not say Apple is moving fast. Most people expected this update 6 months ago.

Since when does Apple make major software update announcements at Christmas?

Re: Apple's On-Device and Server Foundation Models

#199
post #84

Is it me or Apple is really moving fast? I don't think it is easy for a company of this size to concisely put a vision of AI in these short and crazy AI times. BTW, not an Apple fan but an Apple user.

Google had similar AI functionality on Pixels last year and Microsoft had like six AI CoPilot products before that. So I would not say Apple is moving fast. Most people expected this update 6 months ago.

Take a look at the yearly OS cadence. iOS 17 only came out a few months before your 6 month expectation.

Re: Apple's On-Device and Server Foundation Models

#200

For people interested in AI research, there's nothing new here. IMO they should do a better job of referencing existing papers and techniques. The way they wrote about "adaptors" can make it seem like it's something novel, but it's actually just re-iterating vanilla LoRA. It was enough to convince one of the top-voted HackerNews comments that this was a "huge development". Benchmarks are nice though.

> For people interested in AI research, there's nothing new here. Was anyone expecting anything new? Apple has never been big on living at the cutting edge of technology exploring spaces that no one has explored before—from laptops to the iPhone to iPads to watches, every success they've had has come from taking tech that was already prototyped by many other companies and smoothing out the usability kinks to get it r…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN