Live data from Hacker News

Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

nichegamer.com

21–30 of 113 posts

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#21
post #12

Does this only relate to things you put into their cloud, or does Photoshop now upload your offline files to Adobe servers as well? By the way, it's always morally correct to pirate Adobe software for personal use. Which also allows you to fully firewall it because it no longer needs to talk to the activation server.

By pirating, you mean running modified binaries from unknown sources? Morals aside, how is that safe, secure, or even convenient?

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#22

Adobe Photoshop was one of the tools that helped me earn money professionally during my school and college days, so I had a nostalgic relationship with it. Then, I had a good relationship with Adobe in various ways for a long time in the 2000s. I stopped using such tools long back, but I wanted to keep one handy to remind me of the old days. I found Serif's Affinity[1] to be a good alternative so far. I've been a cus…

> The other good, light, quick, and easy-to-use alternative is Pixelmator Pro

Unless you want, e.g., a destructive crop[0] which they have been not adding for at least 4 years and counting. Since my graphic work generally involves cropping, that kinda rules out Pixelmator Pro for me and forces me back into the Adobe Tax Hole.

[0] There are undoubtedly many other deficiencies but this one really irks me.

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#23
post #21
post #12

Does this only relate to things you put into their cloud, or does Photoshop now upload your offline files to Adobe servers as well? By the way, it's always morally correct to pirate Adobe software for personal use. Which also allows you to fully firewall it because it no longer needs to talk to the activation server.

By pirating, you mean running modified binaries from unknown sources? Morals aside, how is that safe, secure, or even convenient?

I'll take my chances. Adobe have proven they want to spy on me 100% of the time and shake me down for as much cash as possible. Pirates ostensibly have to compete on the quality of the product they offer.

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#24
post #18

Unexpectedly fantastic news! My wife makes extensive use of the adobe PDF editing tools, which is has been a major blocker for getting her onto linux. What is a good replacement that works on windows and linux? Non-free is fine.

Have a look at Qoppa, Master Pdf Editor, and Xournal.

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#25
A large swathe of professionals campaigned on behalf of Adobe when they switched from perpetual to subscription licensing. They willingly turned over control and this is merely the consequences of that willingness, which Adobe will continue to take advantage of. I don't see this leading to any changes, just pointing it out.

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#26
post #15

I replaced photoshop with photopea a while ago. I only use it for light work, but it’s the lowest friction alternative I’ve tried that runs on Linux. https://www.photopea.com/

+1 for Photopea! Excellent drop-in replacement for Photoshop and Gimp is always there to help for HDR things that Photopea can't handle.

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#27
post #21
post #12

Does this only relate to things you put into their cloud, or does Photoshop now upload your offline files to Adobe servers as well? By the way, it's always morally correct to pirate Adobe software for personal use. Which also allows you to fully firewall it because it no longer needs to talk to the activation server.

By pirating, you mean running modified binaries from unknown sources? Morals aside, how is that safe, secure, or even convenient?

I've been doing it all my life. I've literally never paid for a software license, I don't know any better. In general, I usually download from reputable sources. Haven't had any problems so far.

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#28
post #21
post #12

Does this only relate to things you put into their cloud, or does Photoshop now upload your offline files to Adobe servers as well? By the way, it's always morally correct to pirate Adobe software for personal use. Which also allows you to fully firewall it because it no longer needs to talk to the activation server.

By pirating, you mean running modified binaries from unknown sources? Morals aside, how is that safe, secure, or even convenient?

We're in a world where the legal solution isn't exactly safe, secure nor convenient either

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#29
post #15

I replaced photoshop with photopea a while ago. I only use it for light work, but it’s the lowest friction alternative I’ve tried that runs on Linux. https://www.photopea.com/

Yup, love photopea.

No need to wait for Photoshop to load and it works on any computer with a browser.

Re: Photoshop ToS grants Adobe access to user projects for 'content moderation'

#30
post #21
post #12

Does this only relate to things you put into their cloud, or does Photoshop now upload your offline files to Adobe servers as well? By the way, it's always morally correct to pirate Adobe software for personal use. Which also allows you to fully firewall it because it no longer needs to talk to the activation server.

By pirating, you mean running modified binaries from unknown sources? Morals aside, how is that safe, secure, or even convenient?

[deleted]
Post reply on HN