Live data from Hacker News

What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

arxiv.org

21–30 of 118 posts

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#21

Huh, so you can hear things explode in space, after all. If you're close enough to a warp field doing funny things, the gravitational wave strain would create audible-frequency artifacts, as it wiggles your eardrums at frequencies close enough to the audible. They derive an equation for estimated strain as a function of distance from the warp bubble collapse. How does strain translate to sound intensity, in the situa…

That ringing in your ears you get once in a while... ?

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#22
post #8
post #6

This is excellent. Like the Dyson sphere, predicting signals for technologies that we can imagine but not yet construct seems like a great way to guide our search for other life. Now we need a team of smart folks to identify tearing or other processing anomalies in universe-scale simulations.

If you like spooky stuff there is lots of fun things to think about. Just off the cuff; We are predicting a soul upload technology with Neuralink etc. So an alien technosignature could look like: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/21_grams_experiment This one is not rigorous but there are lots of other possibilities of this pattern.

That experiment was so poorly performed that it can be completely discounted.

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#23
post #12

Huh, so you can hear things explode in space, after all. If you're close enough to a warp field doing funny things, the gravitational wave strain would create audible-frequency artifacts, as it wiggles your eardrums at frequencies close enough to the audible. They derive an equation for estimated strain as a function of distance from the warp bubble collapse. How does strain translate to sound intensity, in the situa…

Would it even wiggle the eardrums relatively to the rest of your head? Intuitively it seems that would only happen if the wavelength is exactly right, but at that wavelength the frequency would be inaudible because the speed of light is so high.

[deleted]

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#24
post #21

Huh, so you can hear things explode in space, after all. If you're close enough to a warp field doing funny things, the gravitational wave strain would create audible-frequency artifacts, as it wiggles your eardrums at frequencies close enough to the audible. They derive an equation for estimated strain as a function of distance from the warp bubble collapse. How does strain translate to sound intensity, in the situa…

That ringing in your ears you get once in a while... ?

I'm curious about this, sometimes also when one ear suddenly sounds different for a short time.

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#25
post #24
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That ringing in your ears you get once in a while... ?

I'm curious about this, sometimes also when one ear suddenly sounds different for a short time.

That's one of the little hairs in your ear dying. You're literally hearing the sound of your hearing deteriorating.

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's fun that people can get paid to do this.

Why not? People get paid to play video games and any other vast number of examples that break the traditional concept of "job"

I was being genuine. It would be great to have that kind of a job.

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#28

Huh, so you can hear things explode in space, after all. If you're close enough to a warp field doing funny things, the gravitational wave strain would create audible-frequency artifacts, as it wiggles your eardrums at frequencies close enough to the audible. They derive an equation for estimated strain as a function of distance from the warp bubble collapse. How does strain translate to sound intensity, in the situa…

One of the reasons I no longer ask questions on Physics stack exchange:

1. I asked "how powerful" such waves would have to be to be audible.

2. I directly linked to another question whose accepted answer said "these waves can wiggle your ear drum"

3. Got my question closed as a duplicate but the link was to different question that only asked "is it possible" (and accepted the answer "yes") without there being any answer to the "how powerful" part.

4. Got an answer which said "no, never".

Of course, I can now get an infinite supply of confusing contradictions from ChatGPT, and because I ask questions from a position of ignorant curiosity, I'm equally incapable of discerning which of the mutually incompatible responses I get is definitely incorrect regardless of if it comes from an LLM or a trained physicist.

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#29
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm curious about this, sometimes also when one ear suddenly sounds different for a short time.

That's one of the little hairs in your ear dying. You're literally hearing the sound of your hearing deteriorating.

Well, that or earwax.

Re: What no one has seen before: gravitational waveforms from warp drive collapse

#30
post #28

Huh, so you can hear things explode in space, after all. If you're close enough to a warp field doing funny things, the gravitational wave strain would create audible-frequency artifacts, as it wiggles your eardrums at frequencies close enough to the audible. They derive an equation for estimated strain as a function of distance from the warp bubble collapse. How does strain translate to sound intensity, in the situa…

One of the reasons I no longer ask questions on Physics stack exchange: 1. I asked "how powerful" such waves would have to be to be audible. 2. I directly linked to another question whose accepted answer said "these waves can wiggle your ear drum" 3. Got my question closed as a duplicate but the link was to different question that only asked "is it possible" (and accepted the answer "yes") without there being any ans…

The moderation on SE is abysmal, but it's the best moderation around for such a large, universally accessible, user-submitted knowledge store.
Post reply on HN