Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 75 posts

Re: Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

#41

I don't get it. People around me have been saying Google is shit for years now but I can't see it. I still reach for google for any minor query, and it's super responsive and it's super helpful. Yes of course I am aware that for certain queries you get a lot of results that have manipulated their way to the top. I just think I have a very good natural bullshit-filter.

It's definitely crested and the downslope is just really long

Re: Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

#42

A Google query returns in <<500ms (for me anyways). Try that with your shiny LLM's.

Try Claude Haiku if not already. It is very fast and good enough in most cases. Exact comparison number does not matter as it takes me longer to read anyways.

Re: Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

#43
I give them 2-5 years. One thing is crappy search, but another is bad company culture.

On the other hand, their AlphaFold effirts seem to have no real competition, so it would be funny if the whole company pivoted into biotech one day :D

Re: Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

#44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not an answer to your question, but Github code search is great: https://github.com/features/code-search

Yeah I'm really glad GitHub finally has functioning code search (how many years did it take?), but I don't like being forced to use it for simple stuff. It's slow and doesn't include source code or documentation that's not on GitHub. I don't always know in advance whether the answer to my query lives in GitHub or not...

It also requires to log in, AFAIK.

Re: Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

#45
Google's search of Reddit is better than Reddit's search of Reddit. Google AI search can also give you the information you're looking for directly without having to manually filter through a bunch of on page junk (ads, distracting UI, irrelevant content)

Re: Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

#46
post #45

Google's search of Reddit is better than Reddit's search of Reddit. Google AI search can also give you the information you're looking for directly without having to manually filter through a bunch of on page junk (ads, distracting UI, irrelevant content)

> Google AI search can also give you the information you're looking for directly without having to manually filter

It’s especially good when you need to find out the recommended amount of rocks to eat per day

Re: Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don’t like the company and stopped using Google search over 5 years ago. I don’t miss it or even notice its absence. I have to remind myself Google is a massive part of many people’s experience of the internet.

Which company is better? When it comes to that level of data and maturity I think there is no valid competition. I've consciously made the decision that I don't care what Google does with my data. They're going to attempt to track me regardless of if I use their services or not. I have friends who live off grid to get away from internet tracking but I don't envy their lifestyle. So I think like most conscious people…

Why does a single company have to be better? Fastmail or Migadu for mail, Kagi for search. I still use YT on a semi regular basis.

Just because you’re used to using their products and it’s convenient to use them doesn’t mean there aren’t valid alternatives, or that using those equals “suffering”.

That has to be the most first world rant I’ve seen in a while.

Re: Ask HN: Is Google Dead?

#50
post #31

It's the top search engine by a large margin and generates tens of billions of revenue. You can't declare something dead just because you notice a decline in it.

Imagine that you killed the engine of a full load cargo train at full speed, is the train going to stop immediately?
Post reply on HN