Live data from Hacker News

The rise of the disposable car

bloomberg.com

241–250 of 267 posts

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#241

Earlier quoted context omitted.

$800 is steep. I have a 2018 Subaru Outback. I got in a fender bender that caused the right front headlight unit to snap near the top bolt where it attached to the car. I found out when my car failed inspection. I called the dealership and they quoted me $500 just for the headlamp. I went on rock auto and bought one for $250 and installed it. I had to take the front bumper off the car to install the headlamp. Passed…

One Rockauto tip is to Google for a 5% discount code and enter it at checkout. I’ve never not found one.

I had no idea they did discounts Thanks for the tip!

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#242
post #231

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I live in the rust belt, where the average life expectancy of a car is about 10 years. 12-15 if you _really_ baby it. Except for one car that was totaled (got rear-ended by a texter), all of the cars I no longer own succumbed to a rotted out frame. Engines were fine, bodies were fine, interiors were fine. But a frame. Can't really replace a frame. You can _sometimes_ repair it. You can buy some time by paying for an…

> I live in the rust belt, where the average life expectancy of a car is about 10 years. Are you saying the "rust belt" region of the US, named for its history of steel manufacturing, is an area where cars rust more? Cars rust more where salt is used to deice roads. Salted roads overlap with the rust belt, but they are not related.

[flagged]

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#243
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cars more than about 10-15 years old just aren't as safe as newer ones. That's the fundamental issue. With that said there are ways to mitigate the risk (drive more cautiously/slower, etc...).

>Cars more than about 10-15 years old just aren't as safe as newer ones. Can you give some examples? The only safety innovation I can think of recently the side airbags. The backup camera, which is a huge improvement to backing up accidents was probably over 15 years ago.

It's not just active stuff - the passive stuff has improved as well (crumple zones for instance): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TikJC0x65X0&t=19s

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#244

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Side cameras, automatic braking, person avoidance, lane keeping?

I had a vehicle with lane keeping and if I were a cop, I'd think I was drunk the way it weaved back and forth. It was a 2017 though, I hope it's improved but it seemed like a gimmick. I've never experienced the others, are they legit safety features, or just stuff to bullet point?

I've turned off lane keeping on my 2023 Audi A4. However, everything else is useful including and especially the passive improvements.

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#245

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For varying definitions of “governments” and “will”. You’re looking at this from a very western perspective. For example, airbags have proven to drastically increase safety, yet almost a half-century later they’re still not required by many countries across 2 and a half continents. Governments only require safety equipment as far as their population can afford it.

Most governments don't need to as they can leach off of it not being worth making a model without airbags.

Except that didn't happen. Leaving out parts is pretty easy to do, especially when those parts are hundreds of dollars each.

Global automakers have, and still do, make different vehicles for different markets. And further, some only make vehicles for developing economies.

For example, Pakistan required airbags in 2022, and they found necessary to do so because automakers were still making vehicles without them. https://propakistani.pk/2021/12/27/pakistan-to-ban-cars-with...

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#246
post #75

The rich have been flogging this idea since cash for clunkers. That, because they run through cars like shit through a goose, you will too. Speaking as a master diesel mechanic, this is a deleterious line of thinking for anyone with less than a few million dollars. Every car has 20 years of parts, and most Japanese cars have closer into 50 years of parts. Any engine built after 2010 will likely last half a million mi…

(USA specific) Depending on the state, "totaled" might still mean YOU can't fix and drive your car again. In Illinois, you can only retain a totaled vehicle if it was hail damage or it's a "vintage (9+ yr old) car.

Lol 9 years is vintage is lol

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#247
post #114
post #81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At least in my area, the problem is labor costs. If you can do things yourself, it's great. If you need a mechanic to do it, you're looking at a big expense, because mechanic labor is expensive and there's a lot more covers and harder to get to parts these days. 'Maintenance free' transmissions are very common in newer cars, and they do tend to need less maintenance, but when they do, there's often not a great way to…

> 'Maintenance free' transmissions are very common in newer cars I take advantage to your comment to write this PSA (that probably you already know): All transmissions require maintenance, and even manual ones. Those automatic tagged as 'maintenance free' from the brand aren't, and if you call the manufacturer of that transmission, Getrag, ZF, or whatever it is, they should say which ATF and filters it needs and in w…

> ATF and filters it needs

Not all modern transmissions have a filter

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#248

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whatever you save on the upfront cost of a used Q5 you'll pay on the backend the first time it needs service.

It’s a Volkswagen under the hood. Besides some “performance” components most are going to be exactly the same as a Volkswagen.

Depends on what engine you choose… you can get a base model that has an identical simple and reliable drivetrain to a Jetta or Golf, or some exotic engines that are very costly to maintain- like the V6 TDI.

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#249
post #218
post #205

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Checking that state of the fluid isn't difficult, as is bright red when it's new, and turns more and more brown when it's used, and it's mostly used normally between 50k and 100l AFAIK. Yeah, but getting to the fluid to see it is hard. They stopped putting in dipsticks, so hopefully there's a check plug somewhere you can get to.

Some fluids are proprietary, like Nissan’s earlier CVT oil which probably costs more than printer ink. Using some near-beer brand often resulted transmission failure.

If its much more than 100 bucks, I'd be pretty surprised, honestly. A quick google shows most Nissan CVT fluids (even the OEM "unicorn tears") at ~80 dollars for the usual 5 quarts etc. Virtually all the "proprietary" fluids are just rebranded mainstream brands (castrol/Valvoline etc etc), most car OEMs are not in the business of manufacturing their raw fluids themselves.

Re: The rise of the disposable car

#250
I bought a Infinity g35 cash in 2005 and have never let a mechanic touch it. Done all the repairs including ac work myself. There is literally a youtube video that walks you through every step for almost all common repairs for your EXACT model. Its sooo easy and often faster to do it myself instead of go the mechanic and leave it with them multiple days.

I would highly recommend young people buy a popular model or platform based car and just learn how to do mechanic work. Its fun and rewarding.

Car is currently 19 years old going on 20 and besides the initial amount I bought it for it costs me about 200-300 in parts and fluids to maintain. Hats off to the engineers at Nissian. This thing prints money.

Post reply on HN