Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

news.ycombinator.com

71–80 of 90 posts

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#71
At that young age I would recommend working on just generalized cognitive skills. Here is my list of things (off the top of my head) most adults are horrible at. Some child are absolutely gifted in these items, but most are not:

* Number acuity - This is the skill of visually knowing the number of things by looking at a collection of things without using a counting system, for knowing the number of dots on a card instantly from vision only. Some children struggle with as a few as four, but most will average around 6. The most brilliant of people will top out around 11. Tree sloths can do around 40.

* Tree model navigation - This is the abstract skill of navigating data points via node relationships in a large data model. Children are surprisingly better at this than adults, but its still makes for fun puzzle adventures. Females are far more gifted at this than males. Even in programming where this is a very real skill most male programmers who do this for a living are absolutely terrified of it and will make up all kinds of bullshit excuses to avoid reasoning about it.

* Cause and effect - This is far less straight forward than most people consider especially when both the cause and effect are points taken from an abstract set of relations. Adults actually fail at this skill just over half the time.

* Greater than and less than - This is another thing that is less straight forward than it seems and largely accounts of bias. Consider how people apply this form of comparison to non-numeric qualities or falsely equivocate non-numeric qualities to numeric values to ease their own reasoning. Examples may include perceptions of space/distance and whether a thing is better, more important, or more immediate than another thing.

* Measurement - This is another thing most adults, especially programmers, commonly fail at and also accounts for bias. Teach children how to measure things, what constitutes valid measures, when to apply measures, and what defines a measure.

* Listening - Listening is not hearing. Hearing is a physical sensual quality. Listening is an information processing quality necessary for empathy and following instructions. There are many adults that fail at this too for a wide variety of reasons. In childhood experiments males tend to do better at listening if the subject matter relates to an ordered list of instructions despite females measuring absolutely superior in language skills across the board.

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#73

I lead a makerspace at my kids' elementary school. We do no coding or modern making, or whatever it is adult nerds like to play with. Mostly because this age group can't manage it, especially in 40 minute session, and I'm competing with a Lego corner. Mostly we try to get new views on the natural world and get exposed to different tools. This week, we managed to bang out some bee houses of some scrap lumber I had. We…

  light bulbs, batteries and switches, all mounted on wood tiles and connected with alligator clips
I'd love to see a photo of this. Maybe I can replicate it.

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#74

At that young age I would recommend working on just generalized cognitive skills. Here is my list of things (off the top of my head) most adults are horrible at. Some child are absolutely gifted in these items, but most are not: * Number acuity - This is the skill of visually knowing the number of things by looking at a collection of things without using a counting system, for knowing the number of dots on a card ins…

For number acuity, you might like this simple web I created a while ago. Have your child on your lap, open the link on your mobile, make sure volume is turned up, and tap the screen.

https://dots.twilam.com/

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#75

At that young age I would recommend working on just generalized cognitive skills. Here is my list of things (off the top of my head) most adults are horrible at. Some child are absolutely gifted in these items, but most are not: * Number acuity - This is the skill of visually knowing the number of things by looking at a collection of things without using a counting system, for knowing the number of dots on a card ins…

For number acuity, you might like this simple web I created a while ago. Have your child on your lap, open the link on your mobile, make sure volume is turned up, and tap the screen. https://dots.twilam.com/

That’s amazing. These kinds of simple tests/tools offer far reaching rehabilitation and neurological assessment capabilities.

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#76
Have the class teach you how to make a peanut butter and jelly sandwich. Follow their instructions, EXACTLY. If they start off with something like “put jelly on the bread,” put the jar of jelly on the loaf of bread. It’s really fun with kids and they learn a lot about logic. Everyone gets to chime in, the adult looks silly and handles mistakes gracefully, the situation can end up hilarious.

I’ve done this with a kid and also in an intro programming class, and it worked with both age groups.

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#77
What about knot tying? I, and a lot of people I work with are big fans.

They are ancient, but still the preferred method of doing many practical things. That's really something special.

Everyone, myself included, seems to love the ambiance of real candlelight, but for basic, utilitarian stuff like finding my keys in the dark or making a snack in a power outage, I'd rather use an LED.

If I want to hang something I'm just going to tie a knot, and I won't be annoyed at all that I don't have some fancy piece of hardware(Not that I'm against such things for hyper specialized applications or to help people with disabilities).

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#78

1. Snap circuits. 2. Legos. 3. Straw Rockets ( https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/edu/learn/project/make-a-straw-rock... ). 4. 100 yard paper rocket launcher ( https://www.instructables.com/100-Yard-Paper-Rocket-Launcher... ). 5. Alka Seltzer Rockets.

I might have to make some of those straw rockets just for myself :)

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#79

Scale model of the solar system! https://www.exploratorium.edu/explore/solar-system/activity/... Have each kid 'adopt' a planet, give them the materials to construct the planet at the appropriate scale and they tell the group 5 fun facts about their planet when the group walks from Sun to Pluto. It is a WHOA experience for kids and adults about the emptiness of space. Scale for the stamina of your kid group, Pluto is…

Oh yeah I remember doing this with an old science teacher when I was about 14. Our school grounds were pretty big being in a small country town but we couldn’t fit Pluto in without shrinking the sun/planets crazy small.

Re: Ask HN: Seeking ideas for preschool/school projects

#80

Maybe just give some interactive demos to the kids showing the power of modern tech? Animate drawings: https://sketch.metademolab.com/ Generate music, based on ideas from the kids using Suno or Udio. Generate a story with GPT/Claude where kids in the classroom are the characters. Create images using Dall-e 3 and print copies so the kids can take it home. This would probably be of interest to many parents and teachers…

Can confirm the animated drawings. I built a company (dibulo.com) which does that (Age 3-8 mostly, but also adults and seniors seem to like it). We love that kids spend more time coloring than looking at the screen (although it is always a magic moment). We also do not have a lot of interaction with the screen itself and soon gonna add more and more educational elements to it.

That’s really cool.
Post reply on HN