Live data from Hacker News

Laying off George

zeldman.com

51–52 of 52 posts

Re: Laying off George

#51
post #38
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In his defense, he admitted he was reading a script provided to him by HR.

We don't know whether that line was in the script or not. If it was, we can chalk the weasliness up to the whole company (which would surprise me a little - I thought more highly of Yahoo). Incidentally, I agree with the commenters here who've pointed out that the cancellation of the project and layoff itself hardly seem unreasonable or tragic. It's the corporate culture I'm commenting on. If this vignette is indicat…

If it was, we can chalk the weasliness up to the whole company

I find it hard to talk about "the nature" of a company the size of Yahoo - this is more the "weasliness" of some HR employee which didn't get corrected by the structure of the company. Of course, it doesn't say anything about the many brilliant employees that had nothing to do with the layoffs.

Re: Laying off George

#52
post #51
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We don't know whether that line was in the script or not. If it was, we can chalk the weasliness up to the whole company (which would surprise me a little - I thought more highly of Yahoo). Incidentally, I agree with the commenters here who've pointed out that the cancellation of the project and layoff itself hardly seem unreasonable or tragic. It's the corporate culture I'm commenting on. If this vignette is indicat…

If it was, we can chalk the weasliness up to the whole company I find it hard to talk about "the nature" of a company the size of Yahoo - this is more the "weasliness" of some HR employee which didn't get corrected by the structure of the company. Of course, it doesn't say anything about the many brilliant employees that had nothing to do with the layoffs.

I find it hard to talk about "the nature" of a company the size of Yahoo

I don't. I noticed years ago that organizations have distinct characters that seem mostly to trace back to their originators. Sometimes the connection is so strong that it almost seems the company itself has a personality. It's true the effect may weaken as companies get big (bureaucracy is depressingly uniform), and we're talking about patterns not laws (lots of room for individual variation), but what's striking is how noticeable the effect is despite those caveats.

Post reply on HN