Earlier quoted context omitted.
Can the federal government build millions of housing units overnight [1]? No. Can they force insurers to not squeeze auto insurance consumers as hard [2]? No. Can they force automakers to reduce their vehicle prices? No (although they are cooling naturally due to the benchmark rate->auto loans->loan payments being unsustainable). Services remain inflated because of reduced labor force participation, and while immigra…
I think the proximate cause of the problems is the trillions of dollars we printed in the year or two preceding the onset of the inflation: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL . Massive inflation happened right after a government intervention that economics theory would have predicted would cause massive inflation. I’m not sure you could identify a clearer real-world fact pattern for a government policy having an…
The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
11–20 of 44 posts
Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#12Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#13It is an interesting phenomenon, depending on what numbers you chose to look, things can paint a different picture. For example, labor force participation percentages would tell you all those jobs that are being added, are probably going to the same people, as they get to work more than one job to support themselves. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CIVPART
Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#14Earlier quoted context omitted.
I think the proximate cause of the problems is the trillions of dollars we printed in the year or two preceding the onset of the inflation: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/M1SL . Massive inflation happened right after a government intervention that economics theory would have predicted would cause massive inflation. I’m not sure you could identify a clearer real-world fact pattern for a government policy having an…
Why do you think the longer running money printing program, quantitative easing, didn’t increase inflation?
Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#15It is an interesting phenomenon, depending on what numbers you chose to look, things can paint a different picture. For example, labor force participation percentages would tell you all those jobs that are being added, are probably going to the same people, as they get to work more than one job to support themselves. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CIVPART
Seems like an aging population explains most or all of the post-2000 downturn, no? We're currently at a 20 year high of the 25-54 age group's employment: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/LNS11300060
Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#16Earlier quoted context omitted.
Why do you think the longer running money printing program, quantitative easing, didn’t increase inflation?
I mean look at the chart I linked. That's why. QE probably did cause inflation, in asset values, etc. We papered over many of the negative effects through importing cheap Chinese goods and cheap immigrant labor, which was a temporary bandaid that caused other problems.
> The Fed resumed purchasing massive amounts of debt securities, a key tool it employed during the Great Recession. Responding to the acute dysfunction of the Treasury and mortgage-backed securities (MBS) markets after the outbreak of COVID-19, the Fed’s actions initially aimed to restore smooth functioning to these markets, which play a critical role in the flow of credit to the broader economy as benchmarks and sources of liquidity. On March 15, 2020, the Fed shifted the objective of QE to supporting the economy. It said that it would buy at least $500 billion in Treasury securities and $200 billion in government-guaranteed mortgage-backed securities over “the coming months.” On March 23, 2020, it made the purchases open-ended, saying it would buy securities “in the amounts needed to support smooth market functioning and effective transmission of monetary policy to broader financial conditions,” expanding the stated purpose of the bond buying to include bolstering the economy. In June 2020, the Fed set its rate of purchases to at least $80 billion a month in Treasuries and $40 billion in residential and commercial mortgage-backed securities until further notice. The Fed updated its guidance in December 2020 to indicate it would slow these purchases once the economy had made “substantial further progress” toward the Fed’s goals of maximum employment and price stability. In November 2021, judging that test had been met, the Fed began tapering its pace of asset purchases by $10 billion in Treasuries and $5 billion in MBS each month. At the subsequent FOMC meeting in December 2021, the Fed doubled its speed of tapering, reducing its bond purchases by $20 billion in Treasuries and $10 billion in MBS each month.
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/fed-response-to-covid19/
https://www.axios.com/2023/12/09/mortage-rates-housing-marke...
Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#17Earlier quoted context omitted.
I mean look at the chart I linked. That's why. QE probably did cause inflation, in asset values, etc. We papered over many of the negative effects through importing cheap Chinese goods and cheap immigrant labor, which was a temporary bandaid that caused other problems.
With regards to real estate price inflation, I agree with you. Homeowners originated mortgages at 2-3%, allowing real estate prices to run wild at those cheap money rates. It will take years for sellers to make peace with forward looking asset prices at the current benchmark rate (some real estate prices can be supported by cash buyers, but investor demand will be low with the risk free rate where it is at, and incom…
I don’t understand the resistance to acknowledging that inflation is the predictable effect of money printing. The M1 money supply increases from $4 trillion in December 2019 to $20 trillion in June 2022. That’s what’s causing the inflation. It’s a textbook outcome from easily identifiable policy choices.
Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#18Earlier quoted context omitted.
With regards to real estate price inflation, I agree with you. Homeowners originated mortgages at 2-3%, allowing real estate prices to run wild at those cheap money rates. It will take years for sellers to make peace with forward looking asset prices at the current benchmark rate (some real estate prices can be supported by cash buyers, but investor demand will be low with the risk free rate where it is at, and incom…
Lack of supply is the cause in some popular metro areas. But that’s not the whole story. Prices are exploding even in places that are experiencing virtually no population growth. Or where growth is below historic trends. The price of my house has doubled, in a country where population growth has been like 1% annually (and it’s a red county with lots of farmland where building housing is relatively cheap and easy). Th…
Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#19Earlier quoted context omitted.
With regards to real estate price inflation, I agree with you. Homeowners originated mortgages at 2-3%, allowing real estate prices to run wild at those cheap money rates. It will take years for sellers to make peace with forward looking asset prices at the current benchmark rate (some real estate prices can be supported by cash buyers, but investor demand will be low with the risk free rate where it is at, and incom…
Lack of supply is the cause in some popular metro areas. But that’s not the whole story. Prices are exploding even in places that are experiencing virtually no population growth. Or where growth is below historic trends. The price of my house has doubled, in a country where population growth has been like 1% annually (and it’s a red county with lots of farmland where building housing is relatively cheap and easy). Th…
M1 didn't include savings accounts in December 2019 and it does now, that's the majority of M1 diff...
That makes me think your conclusions are based off talking-head points instead of first principles, as when your conclusion hinges on M1 changes, you'd think you'd do a few minutes searching what is M1...
Re: The U.S. economy's big problem? People forgot what 'normal' looks like (2023)
#20Earlier quoted context omitted.
Lack of supply is the cause in some popular metro areas. But that’s not the whole story. Prices are exploding even in places that are experiencing virtually no population growth. Or where growth is below historic trends. The price of my house has doubled, in a country where population growth has been like 1% annually (and it’s a red county with lots of farmland where building housing is relatively cheap and easy). Th…
> The M1 money supply increases from $4 trillion in December 2019 to $20 trillion in June 2022. That’s what’s causing the inflation. M1 didn't include savings accounts in December 2019 and it does now, that's the majority of M1 diff... That makes me think your conclusions are based off talking-head points instead of first principles, as when your conclusion hinges on M1 changes, you'd think you'd do a few minutes sea…
Yep it was an accounting change.
Though the additional wave of stimmy checks plus continued buying of MBS during 2021 was definitely not good for inflation.