Live data from Hacker News

Brutalist Churches

dezeen.com

21–30 of 81 posts

Re: Brutalist Churches

#22
post #7

Shouldn't churches evoke feelings of divinity instead of oppression? (I know it's popular to hate on brutalist architecture, but really isn't a place of worship the last place you'd want it?)

They could soften it up by adding some plants. Eco-brutalist!

Re: Brutalist Churches

#24
Montreal has some great brutalist buildings, and there are few brutalist churches in the east-end of the island. I grew up with many buildings of this style and I must say I've grown fond of them. I know they are seen as cold, but they bring me warmth.

Re: Brutalist Churches

#25
post #7

Shouldn't churches evoke feelings of divinity instead of oppression? (I know it's popular to hate on brutalist architecture, but really isn't a place of worship the last place you'd want it?)

Depends on who you ask. It's a somewhat common belief that churches should be plain and unadorned and that religious art can lead to idolatry. Ideas like that were particularly popular among early Protestants.

Re: Brutalist Churches

#26
post #7

Shouldn't churches evoke feelings of divinity instead of oppression? (I know it's popular to hate on brutalist architecture, but really isn't a place of worship the last place you'd want it?)

Many of the brutalist churches I’ve seen do not, IMO, “evoke feelings of oppression” (aside from any one might have as a result of personal conflict with the religious institution behind them, which is a separate issue.)

Including, I should mention, most of those in TFA.

Re: Brutalist Churches

#29

These all look like churches that I would encounter with blood everywhere in the middle of a first-person shooter. They also look like total acoustical nightmares. All that echo-ey concrete, yikes.

Quake??

Mostly I was reminded of the upside-down church zone of System Shock 2. That's one of the few FPSs I bothered playing.
Post reply on HN