Live data from Hacker News

Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

petoi.com

11–20 of 55 posts

Re: Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

#12

I was looking at https://www.unitree.com/go2/ recently, which seems rather good value I thought. Some of the videos look really impressive, such as the back flips, climbing stairs and the lidar

They do look impressive but the videos are all 3D graphics rather than real. The texture on the robot body and shadows are the giveaway.

Re: Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

#13
post #10

Is it just me, or is $269 monstrously expensive for some injection moulded plastic, plastic geared servo motors, an arduino compatible board, a battery and some connectivity modules?

If you sell hw products and you're not charging at least 4x parts costs you will go bankrupt.

Your parent should really check out the BOM on his iPhone or MacBook before complaining about $270 being "monstrously expensive" hardware. And all those gadgets benefit from high volume discounts on parts, decades of sunk R&D costs and the volume economies of scale, assembled by sweatshop workers, not niche low volume production runs for enthusiasts like this one.

The price of Pizza at your local non-fast-food restaurant is also significantly higher than that of the bulk raw ingredients it's made of. Now also try adding the R&D costs of inventing the Pizza to that see where that gets you.

Re: Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

#14

Is it just me, or is $269 monstrously expensive for some injection moulded plastic, plastic geared servo motors, an arduino compatible board, a battery and some connectivity modules?

Similar to how software engineers get paid $1000s just to keep hitting the keyboard.

Re: Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

#15
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you sell hw products and you're not charging at least 4x parts costs you will go bankrupt.

Your parent should really check out the BOM on his iPhone or MacBook before complaining about $270 being "monstrously expensive" hardware. And all those gadgets benefit from high volume discounts on parts, decades of sunk R&D costs and the volume economies of scale, assembled by sweatshop workers, not niche low volume production runs for enthusiasts like this one. The price of Pizza at your local non-fast-food restau…

she doesn't have an iPhone or a MacBook because I do think they're expensive. I buy my phones used on eBay and cringe if they cost more than £50

Re: Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

#16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your parent should really check out the BOM on his iPhone or MacBook before complaining about $270 being "monstrously expensive" hardware. And all those gadgets benefit from high volume discounts on parts, decades of sunk R&D costs and the volume economies of scale, assembled by sweatshop workers, not niche low volume production runs for enthusiasts like this one. The price of Pizza at your local non-fast-food restau…

she doesn't have an iPhone or a MacBook because I do think they're expensive. I buy my phones used on eBay and cringe if they cost more than £50

How you feel about your SO's phone pricing is besides the point.

The point was that you don't understand the distinction between the retail price of a product and raw BOM costs.

Please read the comments here trying to educate you.

Re: Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

#17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

she doesn't have an iPhone or a MacBook because I do think they're expensive. I buy my phones used on eBay and cringe if they cost more than £50

How you feel about your SO's phone pricing is besides the point. The point was that you don't understand the distinction between the retail price of a product and raw BOM costs. Please read the comments here trying to educate you.

what do you mean about my SO? I was referring to myself

Re: Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

#19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How you feel about your SO's phone pricing is besides the point. The point was that you don't understand the distinction between the retail price of a product and raw BOM costs. Please read the comments here trying to educate you.

what do you mean about my SO? I was referring to myself

Sorry but you did refer to yourself at the third person as "she", so how was anyone supposed to know?

Re: Petoi Bittle – a programmable robot dog

#20

I was looking at https://www.unitree.com/go2/ recently, which seems rather good value I thought. Some of the videos look really impressive, such as the back flips, climbing stairs and the lidar

They do look impressive but the videos are all 3D graphics rather than real. The texture on the robot body and shadows are the giveaway.

Interesting, I didn't actually realise that. Will await to see some reviews :)
Post reply on HN