Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
1–10 of 28 posts
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#2[flagged]
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#3I hope the author will post an official correction/amendment to the original paper and not just leave a short notice on their personal homepage.
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#4Context, eg:
Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems,123 comments
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39998396
and
A quick post on Chen's algorithm, 95 comments
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#5I hope the author will post an official correction/amendment to the original paper and not just leave a short notice on their personal homepage.
Did you check the paper they describe in the note?
"See the updated version of eprint/2024/555 - Section 3.5.9 (Page 37) for details"
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#6I hope the author will post an official correction/amendment to the original paper and not just leave a short notice on their personal homepage.
He has done this, page 37:
https://eprint.iacr.org/2024/555.pdf
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#7[deleted]
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#8I find that this is a great reaction to someone finding a bug in your paper. No trying to cover it up, but straight-up admitting a mistake. Also, the fact that he leaves the paper out because it does contain novel ideas that might be useful for further research is cool.
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#9I love this, great work for science overall. This is exactly the type of approach/response one should take, and I hope he gets praise for doing the right thing.
Re: Quantum Algorithms for Lattice Problems – Update on April 18
#10I find it amazing someone can even read and follow all the formulas and find a bug