Live data from Hacker News

UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time (2019)

debugandrelease.blogspot.com

51–53 of 53 posts

Re: UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time (2019)

#51
post #32

As a counterpoint, when you change the insides, no one notices: https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20040525-00/?p=39... >And with Calc, that’s exactly what happened: Massive technical improvements. No visual improvement. And nobody noticed. In fact, the complaints just keep coming. “Look at Calc, same as it always was.”

If nobody notices massive technical internal improvements, that tells me that what was improved wasn't of great importance to the user in the first place. Perhaps those technical improvements were a waste of time, but perhaps those technical improvements benefited development without adversely impacting users. That would be an enormous "win" in my book. > Anyway, my point is that—whether you like it or not—if you don…

"Second, that comment implies that one way or another, a user-noticeable change must happen. It could very well be that the software is ideal for its user base as-is and no change at all is preferable to change for change's sake."

To quote the users: "but why should I pay for bug fixes?"

User-noticeable change is essential.

Re: UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time (2019)

#52
post #50
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Developers hate to work on frontend implementation I know a lot of developers who strongly prefer front-end work. I know a lot that hate it. A bit like how some developers prefer greenfield development and others prefer maintenance work. I don't think it's supportable to make a blanket declaration that all developers have the same tastes or interests.

>I don't think it's supportable to make a blanket declaration that all developers have the same tastes or interests. Let's make a poll. Why, when CSS is advanced as never before, devs are using Tailwind?

You're talking web development specifically here. I was talking about front-end work generally.

Re: UI redesigns are mostly a waste of time (2019)

#53

Can anyone here explain why YouTube (namely the mobile interface) goes through a total redesign every 1-2 years? Is it just to earn some unknown manager another promotion? I'm getting really sick of it at this point.

it's called resume driven develobment
Post reply on HN