Live data from Hacker News

H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts

theregister.com

11–20 of 230 posts

Re: H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts

#11

Why is there a lottery anyway instead of a salary ranking/salary threshold system? This'd disincentivize bad actors, ensure the US domestic labor pool is not undercut, and (more or less) lead to higher quality H-1B immigrants.

Because regions and industries that pay less would be mad, and they’ve got lots of congressmen.

Re: H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts

#12

Why is there a lottery anyway instead of a salary ranking/salary threshold system? This'd disincentivize bad actors, ensure the US domestic labor pool is not undercut, and (more or less) lead to higher quality H-1B immigrants.

There is a salary threshold, but it is very low, $60k/yr IIRC. It was last updated during the 90s.

A salary ranking scheme would cut most professions out.

Re: H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts

#13

Why is there a lottery anyway instead of a salary ranking/salary threshold system? This'd disincentivize bad actors, ensure the US domestic labor pool is not undercut, and (more or less) lead to higher quality H-1B immigrants.

Because regions and industries that pay less would be mad, and they’ve got lots of congressmen.

That could potentially be solved by having different buckets for different regions and industries? Seems like that'd be a much fairer system than the current lottery one.

Re: H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts

#15
Just question.

For software jobs.

Why is there a demand that can drive abuse. When there are so many people that can't find jobs?

It seems like right now there should not be enough demand for H1-b (for software) to justify abuse. Like it shouldn't be profitable enough.

Re: H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts

#16

Why is there a lottery anyway instead of a salary ranking/salary threshold system? This'd disincentivize bad actors, ensure the US domestic labor pool is not undercut, and (more or less) lead to higher quality H-1B immigrants.

Because regions and industries that pay less would be mad, and they’ve got lots of congressmen.

Set the thresholds using a countrywide baseline (1.0 = countrywide median household income) and adjust according to the median household income of the city the job would be located in. Also adjust thresholds based on the profession.

Re: H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts

#17

Why is there a lottery anyway instead of a salary ranking/salary threshold system? This'd disincentivize bad actors, ensure the US domestic labor pool is not undercut, and (more or less) lead to higher quality H-1B immigrants.

Kickbacks, my guy!

Re: H-1B visa fraud alive and well amid anti-abuse efforts

#18

Why is it suddenly called fraud and abuse when the "immigrants are taking our jobs" but from the upper middle class?

It’s not called fraud and abuse because “immigrants are taking our jobs”. It’s called fraud and abuse because it’s fraud and abuse. It’s been prevalent in the H1B process for years.

Personally, I’m all for America bringing in talented foreign nationals. But the H1B process is bad for foreigners looking to work in the US who get way underpaid and don’t have easy options to work at a different firm. And bad for American workers who have to compete against underpaid wages.

Given that the point of the program is to bring in talent unavailable, it’s become a farce. I think companies hiring H1B’s at below market wages probably think they’re getting a bargain. But I doubt that most of them - maybe other than FAANG - are getting good talent at lowball wages.

It’s a bad program all around.

Post reply on HN