Live data from Hacker News

With Vids, Google thinks it has the next big productivity tool for work

theverge.com

21–30 of 152 posts

Re: With Vids, Google thinks it has the next big productivity tool for work

#21

It's odd to me that they wanted to make a whole new "app" for this, rather than building in some sort of timeline into slides. Powerpoint supports automatically transitioning slides and auto playing video, so with some fancy magic in the export where they slice the video for each slide, you could even do everything in a "compatible" way. Slides would of course be able to keep the video on top of the slides + transiti…

Someone probably wanted a promotion, or to use the latest shiny framework rather than an existing codebase.

Re: With Vids, Google thinks it has the next big productivity tool for work

#22
post #12
post #4

My prediction on this: people will create videos, people will stop attending meeting because "I'll just watch the video offline", people will get crunched and not watch the videos before finally re-scheduling meetings where the authors will step-by-step in the videos and present the content as we used to do with slides.

This is not the point of meetings though. Meetings are for Aligning Stakeholders or Collaborating Across Teams at least in my world. Do you regularly attend meetings to be an audience member?

At various places of employment, /some/ meetings have absolutely been just so. Nothing of day-to-day value was ever communicated in those meetings, and nothing of value was lost when I stopped attending them.

Sprint Demos could also fall into this category if you squint, but at least there is a good chance you pick up something useful

Re: With Vids, Google thinks it has the next big productivity tool for work

#23
post #4

My prediction on this: people will create videos, people will stop attending meeting because "I'll just watch the video offline", people will get crunched and not watch the videos before finally re-scheduling meetings where the authors will step-by-step in the videos and present the content as we used to do with slides.

This sounds awful. Video is the worst way to consume anything technical, for me. Video tutorials and video code walk throughs are completely worthless for most things. I hope this is just another Google product that they shut down in a year and that it doesn't catch on.

There will be a fast follow for video transcription and search in videos so that people end up creating videos that nobody watch but get indexed by some internal system and provide a concise 1-pager for human consumption that should have been the original work output anyway. /s

Re: With Vids, Google thinks it has the next big productivity tool for work

#25
Not bad, so instead of having people spend time making powerpoints and then give presentations while everyone else pretends to listen, now the presenter can auto generate it while everyone else pretends to have clicked the link.

This is a more efficient way to waste time, it might actually succeed in many companies (until Google kills it anyway).

Re: With Vids, Google thinks it has the next big productivity tool for work

#26

It's odd to me that they wanted to make a whole new "app" for this, rather than building in some sort of timeline into slides. Powerpoint supports automatically transitioning slides and auto playing video, so with some fancy magic in the export where they slice the video for each slide, you could even do everything in a "compatible" way. Slides would of course be able to keep the video on top of the slides + transiti…

I think there are a few benefits to doing creating a whole new app. First, a video editing application can become very sophisticated, especially if you want to both offer easy fast creation/editing features but also provide a spectrum where users can opt into more customization or sophistication. Cramming that user interface alongside other UI for slides or whatever will quickly become too crowded and unmanageable, for users but also the teams trying to add more functionality. The second benefit is that a new product lets you have independent flexibility on pricing or usage models. Third, you have the opportunity to perform impactful marketing around something new, as we’re seeing here. Finally, you get to define how users should use the product and incorporate it into their world. If these same features were just in Slides, people may automatically view video creation as a tool to generate content for live slide-driven presentations. But as a separate app, you have a chance to train users to view this as a daily tool that they use for all sorts of communication - both casual everyday chat-like messages and highly-polished presentations.

I have no idea which of these benefits Google is intentional about, by the way - I am just speculating.

Re: With Vids, Google thinks it has the next big productivity tool for work

#29
Probably in response to Microsoft Stream and Zoom Recordings.

Incidentally for the hackers out there: it’s surprisingly easy to build an in-house video sharing platform if you have engineers who like hackathons. I was surprised how little it costs to run in the larger scheme of things, no cloud fees required.

Re: With Vids, Google thinks it has the next big productivity tool for work

#30
post #10
post #4

My prediction on this: people will create videos, people will stop attending meeting because "I'll just watch the video offline", people will get crunched and not watch the videos before finally re-scheduling meetings where the authors will step-by-step in the videos and present the content as we used to do with slides.

> people will create videos, people will stop attending meeting because "I'll just watch the video offline" This is why I have a strong “no recordings” rule for any meeting that benefits from back-and-forth conversation. Especially if it’s a knowledge sharing opportunity like an internal tech talk, brown bag discussion, or similar. Nothing sucks more than presenting a talk to 3 blank squares, getting no questions, an…

You can treat it as recording a YouTube video
Post reply on HN