Live data from Hacker News

Low Cost Robot Arm

github.com

11–20 of 258 posts

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#11
post #8

Anyone know how the accuracy of this compares to the similar-cost adamb314/ServoProject arm? [1] It utilizes a servo mod adding dual encoders to compensate for backlash and achieves accuracy of +/- 0.05mm (enough to thread a mechanical pencil lead in and out of the tip of a pencil). [2] He's been working on the project for 5 years, with significant improvements still in the last year. [3][4] [1]: https://github.com/a…

it should be similar given similar construction; one of the reasons dynamixels tend to be pricey is the dual inboard encoder setup. if price is a factor then a servo+encoders setup will always be cheaper; there are some dirt cheap encoders out there for the creative hacker. dynamixels offer a crappy value compared to DIY solutions, they're just easy to use off-the-shelf and have nice features that aid construction..…

> but hardly anything game changing.

Speak for yourself! When I worked on liquid handlers a decade ago the fully integrated servos were at least ten times as expensive as they are now.

Every time I step away for a few years and jump back in, there seems to be at least a half dozen game changing pieces of hardware on the market.

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#13

Anyone who finds this interesting might also like this one, it‘s not DIY – comes fully assembled: https://www.waveshare.com/roarm-m2-s.htm I have one and the build quality is really impressive for the price point.

How is the software support?

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#14
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

it should be similar given similar construction; one of the reasons dynamixels tend to be pricey is the dual inboard encoder setup. if price is a factor then a servo+encoders setup will always be cheaper; there are some dirt cheap encoders out there for the creative hacker. dynamixels offer a crappy value compared to DIY solutions, they're just easy to use off-the-shelf and have nice features that aid construction..…

> but hardly anything game changing. Speak for yourself! When I worked on liquid handlers a decade ago the fully integrated servos were at least ten times as expensive as they are now. Every time I step away for a few years and jump back in, there seems to be at least a half dozen game changing pieces of hardware on the market.

[deleted]

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#15

I printed a robotic arm for school. Unfortunately, we weren't using a high quality enough printer, so the tolerances were off and things didn't slot together well. I'd recommend people to know the precision of their printer before setting off to build this.

[deleted]

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#16

Anyone who finds this interesting might also like this one, it‘s not DIY – comes fully assembled: https://www.waveshare.com/roarm-m2-s.htm I have one and the build quality is really impressive for the price point.

Nice. What do you use it for?

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#17
I want the arm to wander around my house, pick up articles of loose clothing and put them into washing machine. Then pull them out and spread them on a drying hanger. How far away from that are we?

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#18
Does anyone have any suggestions on something that's a little higher quality, i.e. more torque and larger, like the size of a UR5 but cheaper than $30k? There's always seems to be a gap between "robot arm with dynamixels/off the shelf servos" and "research-grade arms".

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#19
post #17

I want the arm to wander around my house, pick up articles of loose clothing and put them into washing machine. Then pull them out and spread them on a drying hanger. How far away from that are we?

It has been here for several millennia... it even has two legs to walk around and two rotating cameras connected to a very powerful LLM...

Re: Low Cost Robot Arm

#20

The geek in me is drooling, but are there any practical home uses others have found for robotic arms? Hacking is always more fun with a good project

An impractical use would be to have a few of them replace monitor arms in a multi monitor setup. You could then rapidly switch between a few configurations.

Also, have one to stir pasta in the kitchen.

Post reply on HN