Live data from Hacker News

Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

nature.com

111–118 of 118 posts

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don’t think your genetic makeup is an abstraction.

I'm not following your reasoning. It appears to be disjointed. Please explain

Reification is the false assumption of using something abstract to make an objective classification. My point is in this case the underlying is not abstract, it’s as objective as it gets (your genetic makeup is a fact).

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#112
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For visibility, youth suicides are up compared to a low period in the 2000s preceded by higher rates than today in the 90s

It's also interesting how much higher the male suicide rate is.

I couldn't find it mentioned in this article?

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#113
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Conversely, were over-diagnosing and now everyone is ill. Which necessarily follows because the closer you look the fewer people are "normal". In fact I'd go so far as to posit that everyone is aberrant, to nobody's surprise. And of course this is all derivated from a basis of largely qualitative soft-science which had ought be treated as an art than it is a science, however there are pressures which force both pract…

Okay so to summarize, casual dismissal of an entire field of medicine, insinuation that patients are faking mental illness to "look cool," justify their selfish behaviors, or get access to drugs, and that interventions for severe symptoms of mental illness either don't work or make things worse. It really does feel like I was bred in a lab to exist as the counterexample for all this. I was diagnosed with ADHD in midd…

> insinuation that patients are faking mental illness to "look cool,"

This is definitely a thing, it first started getting obvious on Tiktok with Tourette's.

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#115

When I was a kid, it was video games that were ruining a generation, in my parents generation it was "the devils music" that was turning them into a bunch of degenerates. I wonder what the issues where when Galileo was a kid? They title says "epidemic of teenage mental illness", but do we not discriminate between mental illness and mental health? Where is that line? I'm not suggesting social media doesn't have it's c…

People also said cigarettes were bad, or lead pipes.

"People say [thing] is bad, but completely different people 50 years ago said [other thing] was bad" is not really an argument

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#116
post #113
post #78

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Okay so to summarize, casual dismissal of an entire field of medicine, insinuation that patients are faking mental illness to "look cool," justify their selfish behaviors, or get access to drugs, and that interventions for severe symptoms of mental illness either don't work or make things worse. It really does feel like I was bred in a lab to exist as the counterexample for all this. I was diagnosed with ADHD in midd…

> insinuation that patients are faking mental illness to "look cool," This is definitely a thing, it first started getting obvious on Tiktok with Tourette's.

I'm sure this was happening in the sense that you can find any brand of niche crazy if you go looking for it but the "teens getting 'Tourette's'" was a bigger thing and absolutely fascinating. Writing it off as just kids faking it for attention you miss the really cool phenomenon that you can pick up tics like like any other accent's quirks. And just like accents unlearning it is an annoyingly hard process once those brain pathways form.

So they didn't have Tourette's and they weren't faking it, but a seriously cool third thing. Monkey see monkey do is a powerful phenomenon. We just treat it as normal when it happens as part of socialization.

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#117

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not following your reasoning. It appears to be disjointed. Please explain

Reification is the false assumption of using something abstract to make an objective classification. My point is in this case the underlying is not abstract, it’s as objective as it gets (your genetic makeup is a fact).

Things that are grounded can be reified. That's often the case. Grounding gender in chromosomes doesn't mean that gender isn't being reified.
Post reply on HN