Live data from Hacker News

Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

nature.com

101–110 of 118 posts

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#101
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think we may be talking past each other. How does what you're saying relate to the "non binary" concept?

[flagged]

Sure.

This is as absolutely true as saying elements within the universe are fundementally binary, an atom is either hydrogen or helium (with the exception of atomic aberrations).

The math is the same, 2% of elements within the universe are other than H or He, and 2% of human births have chromosomal aberrations.

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Sure. This is as absolutely true as saying elements within the universe are fundementally binary, an atom is either hydrogen or helium (with the exception of atomic aberrations). The math is the same, 2% of elements within the universe are other than H or He, and 2% of human births have chromosomal aberrations.

As an aside don’t astronomers call any non H/He element “metal”?

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

How much do you know about reification as it applies to the field of sociology? It might be something worth looking into.

I don’t think your genetic makeup is an abstraction.

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#106

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sure. This is as absolutely true as saying elements within the universe are fundementally binary, an atom is either hydrogen or helium (with the exception of atomic aberrations). The math is the same, 2% of elements within the universe are other than H or He, and 2% of human births have chromosomal aberrations.

As an aside don’t astronomers call any non H/He element “metal”?

Bang on - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metallicity

To be clearer (and fair to the context): "Pure" intersex is

     conditions in which chromosomal sex is inconsistent with phenotypic sex, or in which the phenotype is not classifiable as either male or female", stating the prevalence of intersex is about 0.018%
whereas more general chromosomal aberrations that deviate from " unquestionably male " or from " unquestionably female " come in at just under 2% (as I recall).

FWiW I believe there's a bit more to behaviour than pure genetics but it's a hard one to pin down; outside of western society there are many places with a long history for not caring about gender nearly as much as abrahamic westerners seem to; the Bugis, pacific sistergirls, etc.

From a datascience perspective there's a non zero number of actual people in Australia that are born intersex and neither male nor female at birth to warrent a non specific gender entry on passport databases .. as a matter of cold pragmatic fact divorced from any "woke" and|or "culture war" politic posturing.

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How much do you know about reification as it applies to the field of sociology? It might be something worth looking into.

I don’t think your genetic makeup is an abstraction.

I'm not following your reasoning. It appears to be disjointed. Please explain

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#108
post #41

I always see discussions on this topic online immediately start discussing how the content of social media is the driver of the mental health issues (comparison to others, everyone projecting their best selves etc). My own experiences with social media and phone addiction leads me to believe its not JUST the content, but also (equally, perhaps moreso) the fact that teenagers AND adults with social media and phone add…

Once I finally actually deleted all of the social media apps from my phone, it suddenly became a really pleasant and useful tool again. I have even started to read ebooks again.

Social media is so much the problem.

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#109

When I was a kid, it was video games that were ruining a generation, in my parents generation it was "the devils music" that was turning them into a bunch of degenerates. I wonder what the issues where when Galileo was a kid? They title says "epidemic of teenage mental illness", but do we not discriminate between mental illness and mental health? Where is that line? I'm not suggesting social media doesn't have it's c…

It’s a tool the way cigarettes are a tool. Taking responsibility means cutting it out of your life.

Re: Is social media behind an epidemic of teenage mental illness?

#110
post #52
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not fitting in is not a mental illness. And this attitude is behind the prevalence of many mental illnesses today. We've gone from a society that embraced difference to one that claims to embrace difference while mandating sameness. TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, etc, are all toxic for this reason.

When did society previously embrace difference?

Maybe embrace is the wrong word. Rather, it was hard for your left hand to know what your right was doing so to speak. So you could easily separate parts of your life. Maybe you were totally normal but had some weird hobby that you engaged in with a group of people every third Saturday. You could successfully construct alternate personae for different groups. Nowadays, your entire life has to be bared out for everyone, and this means that everyone wants to do the same things.
Post reply on HN