Live data from Hacker News

I scraped all of OpenAI's Community Forum

julep-ai.github.io

61–68 of 68 posts

Re: I scraped all of OpenAI's Community Forum

#61
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

FWIW, here are the only links I could find in the article which were tagged "Python3 Package": https://community.openai.com/t/647723 and https://community.openai.com/t/586484 . Note they don't see to have anything to do with the Python package whatsoever. I was pretty disappointed to see this, as I work on the Python package and was hoping for a good place to find feedback (apart from the github issues, which I monit…

Hey! Happy to chat over email/X more closely and help you out. Nomic Atlas automatically generates the labels here. There could be different variations of posts involving the Python Packages. But I did some manual digging & here's what I found; Heading over to the map and filtering by posts around "Python Packages" leads to around 900 posts. Sharing a few examples which do talk about people's posts related to the pyt…

gotcha, that makes sense - thank you!

Re: I scraped all of OpenAI's Community Forum

#62
post #4

Love it, just for the sole reason of turning something OpenAI made into a dataset for everyone else :D

I don’t think OpenAI are gonna lose any sleep over this. Isn’t a “community forum” like this basically just: “we’re not gonna spend money on providing adequate customer support so instead here is a forum where y’all can talk amongst yourselves and we’ll give you some badges and imaginary points for doing the customer support yourselves”?

I believe a community forum is absolutely vital for an "ecosystem" company. There needs to be a town square where people can discuss ideas and share feedback about that particular ecosystem.

OpenAI has a pretty active forum with moderators replying and helping out all the time.

Re: I scraped all of OpenAI's Community Forum

#63
post #6

That's an interesting write-up, I wonder how this would look for other big Discourse communities such as NixOS.

This is definitely a workflow we can package into something open-source. I wonder how the community moderators would like it.

I for one would love it!

Re: I scraped all of OpenAI's Community Forum

#65
post #50
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Is that within the defined data processing purposes of all Discourse setups? It's an optional plugin that can be enabled / disabled by the site admin. Those modules are all disabled by default, and each need to be enabled by the site owner. > Edit: and apparently it also tries to flag NSFW chat messages, does Discourse have PM chats where this would flag private messages for admins to read or is it only public chat…

Of course an admin can always open up the database and read your forum PMs, that's not surprising. The very first line in the link you provided, however, is what I was worried about: > Moderators can read PMs that have an active flag. This system is now setting nsfw flags in an automated fashion, specifically seeking out content that the persons involved wouldn't want others to see. Clearly a forum is the wrong place…

> it is not clear to me who this serves

customers

Re: I scraped all of OpenAI's Community Forum

#66
I saw this part:

> Every Discourse Discussion returns data in JSON if you append .json to the URL.

then this:

> Raw data was gathered into a single JSONL file by automating a browser using Playwright.

Kinda seems to me like having a whole browser instance for this isn't necessary? I would have been surprised if this .json pattern didn't continue for all pages, and it turns out that it does in fact also work for the topic list: https://community.openai.com/latest.json

The other place I've seen this sort of API pattern is reddit. For example, https://www.reddit.com/r/all.json or (randomly chosen) https://www.reddit.com/r/mildlyinfuriating/comments/1bqn3c0/...

Re: I scraped all of OpenAI's Community Forum

#67

I did a bit of data scraping for fun in the past, but I was never quite sure of the legality of what I was doing. What if I was breaking some law in some jurisdiction of some country? Was someone going to track me down and punish me? OpenAI has taught me that no one gives a shit. Scrape the entire internet if you want, and use the data for whatever you feel like.

A precursor to this would have been that Linkedin lawsuit Microsoft lost, allowing that one company to scrape all of Linkedin (technically "public information").

hiQ Labs v. LinkedIn

Re: I scraped all of OpenAI's Community Forum

#68
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> OpenAI has taught me that no one gives a shit. Scrape the entire internet if you want, and use the data for whatever you feel like. Cloudflare gives a shit. My household had to use our 5G internet for most things for a week or two until our IP reputation recovered.

Yeah it’s probably worth renting a server if there’s any doubt about whether it’s wholly appropriate to do something

Some sites just block the entire AWS/GCP ip address range.
Post reply on HN