Live data from Hacker News

Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

collectorsweekly.com

91–99 of 99 posts

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#91
post #28

> I finally discovered that I hadn’t imagined it—it’s a 1977 public information film called “The Finishing Line,” which was made to deter children from playing near railway lines. The film was screened at my junior school https://youtube.com/watch?v=SXGqwCbeFD8

I remember these films, but at the time you don't realize how bizarre they are. What sort of fever dream birthed this script? Who organizes a race where children have to climb through barbed wire fences to cross railway lines?

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#92

I know the 1970s were the malaise decade for a lot of places, but the situation in the UK always seemed... malaisier than anywhere else. What was going on then? I see clips of children's shows from 1970s UK and a lot of them are just creepy and not age-appropriate.

Nothing worked reliably due to constant industrial action. We had a low-level civil war due to the IRA, with bombings being almost routine. We felt like we would be the first to go if the cold war went hot, due to the strategic importance of the radar base at RAF Fylingdales and the USAF base at Greenham Common. The decade was underscored by a pervasive fear of total societal collapse. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T…

Also everything was owned by the government as a result of nationalization following WWII to get everyone working again. And while I believe that a certain level of socialism is necessary, having, for instance, every major British car company owned by the State resulted for the most part in some really boring, really shoddy vehicles, generally painted some grim shade of poo brown. (see also, Yugo, Lada, Trabant, etc)

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#93

I know the 1970s were the malaise decade for a lot of places, but the situation in the UK always seemed... malaisier than anywhere else. What was going on then? I see clips of children's shows from 1970s UK and a lot of them are just creepy and not age-appropriate.

From the fantastic and anarchic Tiswas to… Jim’s Fix It. Perhaps best as a nation if we collectively never mentioned that part of history again.

*Jim’ll Fix It… had to correct as a point of principle!

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Modern slavery system" is hilarious, but even more worrying is claim that one might ever lose the modern society's protrection against being enslaved under some conditions.

I'm not saying we are gonna enslave you. Buuut...

“But you were duly convicted in a court of law…”

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#95
post #9

My favourite, from almost 4 years ago: https://scarfolk.blogspot.com/2020/03/social-distancing-laws...

Given how many people are comparing Scarfolk favourably to Look Around You, I think this image highlights why I feel like it falls well short of that comparison. Looking at the dates on the blog posts, this is more "(then) current year politics in the style of 1970s British local authority PSAs" than anything that actually feels rooted in the time period of the style it's using. There's ones about COVID in 2020, ones…

To each their own. They have similar-ish (i.e. retro) styles, but their aims are not identical. Certainly, the intent of Scarfolk is to be eerie, whereas Look Around You is not intended to be creepy, merely absurdist, which is another area of contrast. I don't think either is better than the other.

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#96

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nothing worked reliably due to constant industrial action. We had a low-level civil war due to the IRA, with bombings being almost routine. We felt like we would be the first to go if the cold war went hot, due to the strategic importance of the radar base at RAF Fylingdales and the USAF base at Greenham Common. The decade was underscored by a pervasive fear of total societal collapse. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T…

We also had the sugar shortage in 1974 https://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/2010/jul/09/archive-... ... and the cod wars (not a typo), and a potato shortage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cod_Wars https://rulesfoolsandwisemen.blogspot.com/2019/02/the-1970s-... Both of which hit fish and chip supplies! https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1975/jul/... https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/…

Also the bread strikes in the late 70s.

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quote: “Slavery was never abolished, it was only extended to include all the colors”

Hmm, cute but I think all this talk of wage slavery kind of downplays the horror of the original. I mean I don't like getting up in the morning either, but really?

It also downplays the horrors of current slavery that people are subject to around the world.

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#98
post #8

Sadly the TV show was never made: https://www.comedy.co.uk/tv/scarfolk/ Scarfolk Merchandise: https://saatchistore.com/catalogsearch/result/?q=scarfolk

I can't help but feel that the TV show would've ruined it, like Scarfolk only works if you only have a certain amount of it and the TV show would've pushed it from "wait, was that real?" to "Ah, right, that's from that show".

Re: Visiting Scarfolk, the most spectacular dystopia of the 1970s (2016)

#99
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you an AI?

I'm thinking of starting a social club for people who have been accused of being an AI on HN. We can have secret meetings, and ice cream on Thursdays ...

Certainly, I can provide some feedback on a proposal to start a social club for people who have been accused of being an AI on HN. That sounds like a grand idea.
Post reply on HN