Live data from Hacker News

Gigantic new aircraft design aims to create the largest plane ever to fly

cnn.com

1–10 of 37 posts

Re: Gigantic new aircraft design aims to create the largest plane ever to fly

#3
I guess it has an advantage that it doesn't have to take off fully laden from such a short runway.

It reminds me of visiting the Upper Peninsula of Michigan, where there was a bike path on an old rail line, and the grade was surprisingly steep. But I realized that the trains would only carry a load when going downhill -- from the ore mines to the shipping port, and would climb the grade empty.

Re: Gigantic new aircraft design aims to create the largest plane ever to fly

#4
Doesn't make intuitive sense to me why you'd need a whole new airplane for this. Can you not rig something up to let one of these blades ride on top of an existing plane like the space shuttle transporter? Or would Sergey Brin's giant dirigible work? Or two helicopters flying in formation? Or just make the blades come in two pieces assembled on site?

Just seems very hard to believe a project as massive as a whole new airplane is the best solution to this problem.

Re: Gigantic new aircraft design aims to create the largest plane ever to fly

#5
Submitted a week ago too. I really had a fun time running the numbers & trying to scope what they're trying to do against existing planes & existing windmills.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39690182 80 points, 7 days ago, 131 comments

Re: Gigantic new aircraft design aims to create the largest plane ever to fly

#9
post #4

Doesn't make intuitive sense to me why you'd need a whole new airplane for this. Can you not rig something up to let one of these blades ride on top of an existing plane like the space shuttle transporter? Or would Sergey Brin's giant dirigible work? Or two helicopters flying in formation? Or just make the blades come in two pieces assembled on site? Just seems very hard to believe a project as massive as a whole new…

It all depends on how big the "wind turbine blade shipping" problem is - and how big it'll be in future.
Post reply on HN