Live data from Hacker News

'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

abcnews4.com

221–230 of 505 posts

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#221
post #80

Every single person in the previous thread who ridiculed others for saying that suicide was _not_ the most likely explanation needs a serious re-evaluation of their priors.

also everyone saying they wouldn’t avoid certain planes and there is so much redundancy that little simple non-aviation folks shouldn’t worry themselves.

We’ve got a fishy death, no documentation on the door plug, and more incidents.

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#222

These kinds of things happen and the waters immediately get murky. Even those closest to the person in question are never really 100% sure. Reminds me of the death of journalist Michael Hastings in 2013. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Hastings_(journalist)#... Richard Clarke's assessment seemed to carry the weight of truth. But only to a point. Just enough to engage the suspicions of family and friends, but no…

In my view, almost all of these are accidents or suicides and people watch way too many hollywood films. The Hastings thing is classic mania for those of us who know people who have experienced that.

But people _do_ die when exposing corruption of the rich. Such as Daphne Caruana Galizia and Ján Kuciak for the Panama papers. Would you call their deaths "hollywood films"?

And it'd be natural to think killers would try to hide their traces, such that most such deaths would look like an accident or suicide.

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#223

These statements would only be meaningful if suicidal people couldn't say them. No one ever seems to invest in a security system, or a gun, when they make these statements. Why?

Bro, where do you get your food? Do you grow it in your house? Where do you get your water from? Hell, where do you get your air from? How do you think getting a security system fixes it?

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#224
post #139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Assange talked about his dead man's switch previously. If it weren't for that the powers that be probably would have Putined him.

Is that plausible, though? Why would he not have used that leverage to prevent captivity?

I don't know. He never talked about a captivity switch.

Perhaps he is an object lesson that one should create a "switch escalator".

Perhaps a dead man's switch used in captivity could also potentially make captivity worse and remove what last remnants of hope he has. I suspect if he pulled the switch now then a lot of the sympathy he got for exposing a war crime might go out the window.

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#225

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I could certainly believe Boeing would do something like that before I'd ever imagine eBay would, yet eBay did what they did. The stakes are MUCH higher for Boeing, and we already know quite well that Boeing decided to put many human lives at risk to save money, and that's already resulted in many deaths. And they have a long history of making products designed specifically for killing humans. https://www.boeing.com/…

Boeing also has very privileged relations with various three letter agencies.

Indeed.

https://www.spiegel.de/international/germany/bnd-intelligenc...

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#226
post #71

No. If you’re concerned that you might get murdered, and want to make it clear that you have no intention of killing yourself, telling your one friend about it in a conversation in the midst of moving a sofa with no records to prove it whatsoever is the worst possible way of doing it. Tweet it, send it in a message, leave a note in your home. But, “hey push that side, and let’s lift this in 3..2…. oh by the way I hav…

While evaluation of someone's behaviour to work out the truth is a valid endeavour, I find people have a tendency – and I notice it often in our community – to expect perfect rationality in humans at all times. I guess as it makes it easier to criticise them. People who are stressed, sick, anxious, depressed etc often operate more on emotion and in aa reactive way rather than with foresight, clarity and rationality.

I mean, yes, but when we take irrationality into account, we can't discount the irrationality of saying "if it's suicide, it's not me" to a friend, and then committing suicide right after.

My point isn't about what he supposedly did made sense or not, but what he did was completely useless if true, and even debating it is useless now because of the way it was done. That's why I mentioned how he cursed his friend with that.

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#227
post #126
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You put the gun in their hands after you shoot them, as in every movie ever.

Firing a gun leaves residue on your hands etc. They can tell whether you fired it

They can tell whether you fired A gun, not necessarily that you fired that specific gun into your specific body. It's circumstantial evidence at best.

Better evidence would be signs of a struggle or calculating bullet velocity to see if it came from the gun in that position. However, there are ways of doing this without actually causing a struggle. Wait for them to go to sleep; you could even give them some melatonin or something to make them drowsy. If it's in a car, put some nitrogen canisters on the A/C intake to make them pass out.

If it is nefarious, there will be evidence somewhere. Whether you care to look for that evidence, know where to look for it or have the technology to find it ... that's another matter altogether.

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#228
post #71

No. If you’re concerned that you might get murdered, and want to make it clear that you have no intention of killing yourself, telling your one friend about it in a conversation in the midst of moving a sofa with no records to prove it whatsoever is the worst possible way of doing it. Tweet it, send it in a message, leave a note in your home. But, “hey push that side, and let’s lift this in 3..2…. oh by the way I hav…

So you’ve never made a comment about something in passing that turned out to be true? Completely reasonable for this to be said in conversation with a friend but not taken seriously enough to write it down.

I'm not arguing that at all. See my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39713557

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#229
post #166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would think that you are implicitly stating your want to live by the fact you are alive. Also - would all that really move the needle? Surely the only way is 24/7 surveillance. Even then I'm sure there are remote methods of execution that seem natural...

so all suicides are murders?

[deleted]

Re: 'If anything happens, it's not suicide': Boeing whistleblower before death

#230
post #12

Oh so in Russia its jumping out a window and in the USA its some random method of suicide? Why not be specific, and consistent, like Russia?

Because in Russia it is an open message to the public 'don't mess with the KGB or we kill you and maybe your children'. Everybody knows and understands who is the sender and the message. Classic mafia move of intimidation. It is a message to the living. In the Western World the secret services kill to silence people, not to broadcast messages to the public. Quite the opposite PR strategy.

Everyone with career sense in Russia will deny that, of course. They probably even believe it, in the sense that they're so indifferent to the truth of the matter that they don't even feel they are lying when they say the window-jumper was just a suicide and accusing FSB is preposterous.

Maybe you'll find a few who will say, off the record, that of course it wasn't a suicide.

But those people aren't rare in the US either! Feds are just as "paranoid" as the rest of in these matters.

Post reply on HN