Live data from Hacker News

Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

arstechnica.com

1–10 of 120 posts

Re: Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

#2
Im in Utah which has this law. Now pornhub is effectively inaccessible because Im not giving them my ID but I think it largely backfired because everyone uses offshore sites now. Tbh Im kind of grateful because the offshore sites have much better content since its all pirated, but I never wouldve even thought of them until I was kicked off ph.

Re: Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

#3
The slow drip of government interference means people forget what a free and open interent was like. Slowly, its becoming segmented by chickenshit regulation, censorship, and corporate control. We don't care because its only Texas and its adult content, but this is what the slow chipping away of freedom looks like: the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

Re: Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

#5

Im in Utah which has this law. Now pornhub is effectively inaccessible because Im not giving them my ID but I think it largely backfired because everyone uses offshore sites now. Tbh Im kind of grateful because the offshore sites have much better content since its all pirated, but I never wouldve even thought of them until I was kicked off ph.

On the other side of that, the pornography is also likely to be dodgier and the sites shadier. Not saying Pornhub isn't, but it had that cull a while back, and it seems to be trying to be semi-above board, and that can't be said for every site. And "the children" are still able to access pornography.

Nobody wins, except those offshore sites, and I guess the prudes who are only in it for the sound bite.

Re: Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

#6
post #3

The slow drip of government interference means people forget what a free and open interent was like. Slowly, its becoming segmented by chickenshit regulation, censorship, and corporate control. We don't care because its only Texas and its adult content, but this is what the slow chipping away of freedom looks like: the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

> free and open interent

I have already forgotten all about the open interent, all we're left with is this internet thing full of closed gardens with nations each trying to claim parts of it fall under their jurisdiction.

Re: Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

#7
post #3

The slow drip of government interference means people forget what a free and open interent was like. Slowly, its becoming segmented by chickenshit regulation, censorship, and corporate control. We don't care because its only Texas and its adult content, but this is what the slow chipping away of freedom looks like: the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

> slow drip of government interference means people forget what a free and open interent was like

Not sure what about any of this is slow or quiet.

Re: Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

#8

Im in Utah which has this law. Now pornhub is effectively inaccessible because Im not giving them my ID but I think it largely backfired because everyone uses offshore sites now. Tbh Im kind of grateful because the offshore sites have much better content since its all pirated, but I never wouldve even thought of them until I was kicked off ph.

On the other side of that, the pornography is also likely to be dodgier and the sites shadier. Not saying Pornhub isn't, but it had that cull a while back, and it seems to be trying to be semi-above board, and that can't be said for every site. And "the children" are still able to access pornography. Nobody wins, except those offshore sites, and I guess the prudes who are only in it for the sound bite.

Right as I said it backfired. Now the government has legit zero control over porn consumption, where before revenge porn and the like was inaccessible as ph would take it down.

Re: Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

#9
post #3

The slow drip of government interference means people forget what a free and open interent was like. Slowly, its becoming segmented by chickenshit regulation, censorship, and corporate control. We don't care because its only Texas and its adult content, but this is what the slow chipping away of freedom looks like: the road to hell is paved with good intentions.

An alternate point of view is that one day we will look back with deep shame at this hopefully brief period where we made porn and gambling available to children instantly in limitless quantities.

Not saying it’s easy to figure out how to accomplish change in a free and fair way. But the status quo is pretty clearly a horrifying outcome.

Re: Porn Sites Need Age-Verification Systems in Texas, Court Rules

#10
> Texas cannot enforce a provision requiring porn websites to "display health warnings about the effects of the consumption of pornography."

Well at least some common sense prevailed, there is zero reason to have a notice like that.

Like I kinda get on paper how you could come to the conclusion of needing to do something like this (the ID part), I mean generally (unless you look a certain age) you do have to show your ID to buy porn or any related places...

But it just feels unnecessary and reeks of data collection that could be used for bad reasons.

I know I started looking at porn at... middle school timeframe. Maybe freshman of high school but pretty sure middle school. So 13/14 years old time frame.

I am just fine. I am not saying that kids should have free access to it, but we need to remove this stigma.

Post reply on HN