Live data from Hacker News

Bookish Diversions: Do Audiobooks Count?

millersbookreview.com

91–92 of 92 posts

Re: Bookish Diversions: Do Audiobooks Count?

#91

Treating all audiobooks equally is a mistake. Audio books are a transformation function applied to physical books. Asking whether they count as books is asking the wrong question. The more important question is: "what am I trying to get out of reading this book? And will an audiobook help me to do this better?" The answer to this question will be unique to every person and every book. I read quite a few books for the…

I like your way of thinking about Audiobooks as "Audio books are a transformation function applied to physical books."

They also help sometimes in getting the "musicality" of a work. I didn't know how musical Moby Dick was until I heard the audiobook narrated by Frank Muller. He transformed the whole thing. Like when one reads Shakespeare and only afterwards watches it live.

I tend to have audiobook+book combos for almost every book I love, since it's also a good way to continue "reading" even when ones eyes are tired...

Re: Bookish Diversions: Do Audiobooks Count?

#92
post #57
post #23

Spotify etc. helped curb piracy because it was convenient. Ebooks should be convenient, but are not. The experience is much worse than physical books and barely any cheaper. It pains me everytime I try to buy one. Then came the ipad, and while the ipad is terrible for long reading it isn't obvious why an ebook would be better so most dismiss it right away.

It is dismaying that used paperbacks are often cheaper than e-books. I am ashamed to admit that often buy used paperbacks, despite the negative ecological impact of shipping.

Duuuude, who brainwashed you?

Jk, there are so many _worse_ things you could do.

Kudos for buying used paperbacks!

Post reply on HN