Live data from Hacker News

Is it time to stop writing headlines that end in question marks?

elezea.com

21–30 of 39 posts

Re: Is it time to stop writing headlines that end in question marks?

#23
Recently, I was in a group, and it came up that we don't know why people join the organization and what they want to get out of it. So I asked, why don't we know these things? This question was met with emotional violence. I suspect that the reaction to interesting questions is a litmus test of the intellectual health of an organization.

Arguably, a natural reaction to a question that evokes a strong feeling is to take that as an attack. (Example: If the world was created in 6000 years, how did these seashell fossils get inside mountaintop rock strata?) Often, this natural reaction cuts off an opportunity to learn something interesting.

Re: Is it time to stop writing headlines that end in question marks?

#24
post #6

My pet peeve. This was closely watched at Techcrunch and we mocked other blogs (and our own bloggers) who fell back on it frequently (pronouncing titles with question marks with an inflection). Using a question mark just means you aren't sure of your position or what you are trying to say. It makes it easier to sit on the fence and not really say anything, playing it safe. I think most readers prefer a firm opinion o…

Then how does one write about interesting open questions? If the implicit assumption that there aren't any interesting open questions, then I have doubts. Such a field should be a mature industry, and not a field for startups or serious research.

Re: Is it time to stop writing headlines that end in question marks?

#27
Whenever I encounter a rhetorical question in a headline or link, I assume the author is either going to reach some foregone and facile answer, or no answer at all.

In this sense, questions as headlines are not only linkbait; they're often the signs of worthless articles, usually consisting of regurgitated common sense, or else poorly distilled coverage of superior source material.

There are occasional exceptions, to be sure. But generally, if I can guess what answer an author is going to get to long before he gets there, he's wasting my time.

Post reply on HN