Live data from Hacker News

Apple will cut off 3rd-party appstore updates if iPhone is not in EU for a month

theverge.com

21–30 of 80 posts

Re: Apple will cut off 3rd-party appstore updates if iPhone is not in EU for a month

#21
As someone who used to be in the field of public relations before starting a career in software - I don't understand why they are doing this. Surely they realise that this stuff is going to end up on mainstream media and damage their image?

EDIT: I get what people are saying about the App Store fees but reputational damage does cost money, possibly quite a lot.

Re: Apple will cut off 3rd-party appstore updates if iPhone is not in EU for a month

#22
Though I’m happy to see the 3rd party apps - I really don’t get why people even buy apple devices if they want to side load or do other such things.

In terms of camera quality, battery life, or any single criterion it’s not like apple devices are the best anyway.

As a side note - I really don’t understand the logic that leaves gaming consoles exempt.

As a second side note - how is apple even determining if you are an EU citizen or in an EU country? Presumably GPS, but is the implication that EU users must phone home to apple every 30 days?

Re: Apple will cut off 3rd-party appstore updates if iPhone is not in EU for a month

#23
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple says you must be physically located in an EU country to be eligible, as determined by your device, so presumably they are checking GPS and/or cellular location data rather than just IP geolocation.

Even if on-device location is disabled?

In that case they'll probably either (a) ignore your setting and check anyway because the OS can do whatever it wants, or (b) default to "not EU" mode until you agree to turn location services on. They're not going to give you an easy workaround, Apple has made it clear they're going to do the bare minimum they can get away with.

Re: Apple will cut off 3rd-party appstore updates if iPhone is not in EU for a month

#26
post #21

As someone who used to be in the field of public relations before starting a career in software - I don't understand why they are doing this. Surely they realise that this stuff is going to end up on mainstream media and damage their image? EDIT: I get what people are saying about the App Store fees but reputational damage does cost money, possibly quite a lot.

Who needs reputation when you can have a 30% cut of every microtransaction game instead?

Re: Apple will cut off 3rd-party appstore updates if iPhone is not in EU for a month

#27
post #21

As someone who used to be in the field of public relations before starting a career in software - I don't understand why they are doing this. Surely they realise that this stuff is going to end up on mainstream media and damage their image? EDIT: I get what people are saying about the App Store fees but reputational damage does cost money, possibly quite a lot.

It can’t possibly hurt more than what they gain from racketeering

Re: Apple will cut off 3rd-party appstore updates if iPhone is not in EU for a month

#28

I think this third party appstore is an existential threat to apple in the sense that no one jailbreaks there iphone, because they need legit apps, but if the EU allows third party apps stores, then Americans could start jailbreaking their phones and just using third party app stores.

How is that an existential threat to apple though? Don't they profit from selling the physical phones?

Re: Apple will cut off 3rd-party appstore updates if iPhone is not in EU for a month

#30
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even if on-device location is disabled?

In that case they'll probably either (a) ignore your setting and check anyway because the OS can do whatever it wants, or (b) default to "not EU" mode until you agree to turn location services on. They're not going to give you an easy workaround, Apple has made it clear they're going to do the bare minimum they can get away with.

In that scenario, future policy authors would thank Apple for free legislative fuzzing.
Post reply on HN