Live data from Hacker News

Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

esquire.com

141–150 of 185 posts

Re: Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

never heard about this before! thanks for the tip will check this out

Agreed that the SciFi channel miniseries of Dune is top notch. There’s also a Children of Dune miniseries with the same cast. Catch is when I wanted to watch it last these couldn’t be streamed anywhere legally. So I bought them on dvd from fleabay.

The same cast except for Jessica. Alice Krige is amazing in other things, but my Jessica was Saskia Reeves.

Re: Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For that 6-8 part series, you’re looking for the SyFy Channels version that was done early 2000s. Fantastic. Frank Herbert’s Dune. Had William Hurt in it.

Hurt was the worst part of it. I swear, I still cringe when I remember his unemotional delivery of "Desert. Power." Damn he was bad.

lol, never said he was good, only that he was in it. He lended that hollywood stamp and then just trailered his performance.

Re: Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

#143

Historically, february is the time of the year where studios tend to offload the films they think are going to flop. Maybe that has changed.

Dune: Part Two was actually scheduled for release end of last year, but got delayed due to the writers' strike. Maybe it hasn't changed afterall.

Right, but it's not like they had to release it now. My comment was more speaking to the peculiarity of releasing a potential blockbuster at this time of year. They could have made a summer or spring release as well.

Re: Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only Arrival and Interstellar were released in the last decade, and Interstellar only just . This is my point. The last decade has been a sci-fi wasteland.

Plenty of good sci-fi, but mostly on TV. Still, you're also probably overlooking how common sci-fi films are. Like say, Ad Astra with Brad Pitt (2019). The Martian in 2015. Blade Runner 2049 . And so on.

> Plenty of good sci-fi, but mostly on TV.

Care to share? I can't name a single one besides 'The Expanse'.

Re: Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

#145
post #133

How is Austin Butler's character? If he can pull off this _and_ Elvis he can be one of the great actors of our time.

He's alright, I liked Sting much more, and to me (never having read the books) he seems too young, but in the end I guess he does pull it off

Re: Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

#147
post #104

I loved the book but the story imo has not aged well. Too much of white savior going on and too much colonialism. I would not describe myself as "woke", I can see why the teenage me loved it, yet my adult self cringes too hard. Particularly now as multiple post-colonial wars are happening. Also, I do not think a mega-promoted mega-budget Hollywood blockbuster needs more marketing here. "Esquire says" - so what?

Hmm... I think their present-day (post 9/11) problem is rather that the heroes are Arab-inspired and talk of Jihad...

Re: Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

#148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Plenty of good sci-fi, but mostly on TV. Still, you're also probably overlooking how common sci-fi films are. Like say, Ad Astra with Brad Pitt (2019). The Martian in 2015. Blade Runner 2049 . And so on.

> Plenty of good sci-fi, but mostly on TV. Care to share? I can't name a single one besides 'The Expanse'.

Andor, Severance, and Devs come to mind, even though they're different types of thrillers to some extent.

Have heard good things about Station Eleven.

Even on Apple TV+ alone there are plenty to choose from, though funnily enough the one I've been watching the most is not the critically-acclaimed For All Mankind, but climate disaster drama Extrapolations: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39543480

Fired on Mars on MAX is a gem of an existential sci-fi dry comedy.

Paper Girls on Amazon Prime has been cancelled, but it was a good time travel romp and comic book adaptation that wasn't a superhero one from the big two (it's an Image Comics title)

It's not quite the '90s extravaganza in terms of television sci-fi, but with all of the demand for streaming content, the odds are good, even if the goods are often odd. There's been like, three different Star Trek shows now, plus a cartoon. Surely there's something to be found from that.

Re: Dune: Part Two Is the Best Sci-Fi Film of the Decade

#150
post #16
post #12

I just came back from the theater. Every word of this article rings true. The movie is a piece of art, the best of star wars with the grandeur of Game of Thrones. Its very rare to get movies like this these days.

What were your feelings about part one, if you saw that back when it came out?

Watched the part one on day 1 as well. It was definitely more intriguing than enjoyable. The visuals and soundtrack really carried it despite the pacing. Imo, part one was just a great setup for this masterpiece.
Post reply on HN