Live data from Hacker News

Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

macrumors.com

11–20 of 81 posts

Re: Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

#11

>> The reports all mention that the crack became visible suddenly and for no apparent reason, after the headsets had been connected to the external battery pack and stored overnight (some in Apple's Travel Case) with the soft front cover attached. It is glass. The device was being charged, which means some heat gradient between the charging battery and the outside world. That thin 3d-shaped glass cracks under thermal…

> That thin glass cracks under thermal stress should be no great surprise.

Actually, the thinner the glass is, the less likely it is to crack due to thermal gradients. It is thicker glass which experiences greater stress. The equation for thermal stress is:

thermal_stress = (coefficient of thermal expansion) ∙ Young’s modulus ∙ ∆T

which for glass, works out to about 0.63 MPa per 1 degC temperature difference between the centre and edge of the glass. Thinner glass has less temperature difference, so lower stress. Furthermore, surface roughness and type of imperfections lower the amount of stress needed to cause a failure, so Apple's obsessive polishing makes the glass withstand higher stress than usual.

Re: Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

#12
It would never occur to me to store the device connected to its battery inside the case — or outside the case, for that matter.

I don't like the idea of that dense, heavy battery potentially getting displaced from the holding strap in the case cover and banging around inside against the Vision Pro.

Since I got mine February 2 I've kept both my batteries attached to chargers when not in use.

Re: Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

#14

>> The reports all mention that the crack became visible suddenly and for no apparent reason, after the headsets had been connected to the external battery pack and stored overnight (some in Apple's Travel Case) with the soft front cover attached. It is glass. The device was being charged, which means some heat gradient between the charging battery and the outside world. That thin 3d-shaped glass cracks under thermal…

> That thin glass cracks under thermal stress should be no great surprise. Actually, the thinner the glass is, the less likely it is to crack due to thermal gradients. It is thicker glass which experiences greater stress. The equation for thermal stress is: thermal_stress = (coefficient of thermal expansion) ∙ Young’s modulus ∙ ∆T which for glass, works out to about 0.63 MPa per 1 degC temperature difference between…

Thanks for the info and model! But if the thin glass is bonded to the aluminum frame by glue, would that not change the calculus? If we imagine hot air on one side of the thin glass and cold aluminum on the other?

I’m very skeptical of the “charging thermals cause cracks” theory, seems more likely that minor manufacturing defects might do so when the headset cools from a session. But I suppose we’ll hear more than we want to in the next few weeks.

Re: Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

#15

Why is it glass with a plastic coating instead of solid plastic? Apple's use of glass has to be part of a scheme to make money replacing glass parts.

Maybe it has desirable properties compared to plexi.

Re: Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

#16

Why is it glass with a plastic coating instead of solid plastic? Apple's use of glass has to be part of a scheme to make money replacing glass parts.

Maybe it has desirable properties compared to plexi.

Polycarbonate would be a better choice than plexiglass/acrylic. What advantages does glass have? More likely to break and more repairs?

Re: Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

#18

>> The reports all mention that the crack became visible suddenly and for no apparent reason, after the headsets had been connected to the external battery pack and stored overnight (some in Apple's Travel Case) with the soft front cover attached. It is glass. The device was being charged, which means some heat gradient between the charging battery and the outside world. That thin 3d-shaped glass cracks under thermal…

There's no battery behind that glass, so it's the processors or another component generating heat while stored.

> Given that the battery is external to the headset, any heat generated would presumably need to be caused by a background software process gone haywire.

Apple is very good at background software processes taking 100%-500% cpu (100% == one core in Apple land).

Re: Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

#19

Why is it glass with a plastic coating instead of solid plastic? Apple's use of glass has to be part of a scheme to make money replacing glass parts.

But plastic easily scratches? The real question is why it is plastic over glass instead of plastic under glass. Though, I'm kind of thinking they might have realized this could happen and so wanted to safety of the plastic in front of the glass lest users accidentally cut themselves on the broken glass :/.

https://youtube.com/shorts/kuiwxZS4GJE

https://youtube.com/shorts/5Wsmz7sjOb4

Re: Handful of Apple Vision Pro units develop identical crack in cover glass

#20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe it has desirable properties compared to plexi.

Polycarbonate would be a better choice than plexiglass/acrylic. What advantages does glass have? More likely to break and more repairs?

scratches. its all about scratches.

any poly will scratch pretty easily compared to glass, which is a bad thing when its a lens you are looking through. You could make the argument they could just design an easily replaceable poly lens at a reasonable price, but.....its 2024 device manufacturers hate the idea of any user replaceable parts.

Post reply on HN