Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

supermaven.com

21–30 of 104 posts

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#21

- No details at all on the official extension page in VSCode - I bite the bullet and try anyway - No immediate confirmation after setup - Only one configuration option (log file path) - After I start typing into a buffer, the onboarding notification requires sign-in - Sure, why not - "Link to IDE?" - heck yeah, let's finally go - Sign up for a trial - um... - Requires a CC for a 30-day free trial Respectfully, this i…

Sorry. We should be more clear about the CC being required to sign up for the free trial.

[deleted]

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#22

- No details at all on the official extension page in VSCode - I bite the bullet and try anyway - No immediate confirmation after setup - Only one configuration option (log file path) - After I start typing into a buffer, the onboarding notification requires sign-in - Sure, why not - "Link to IDE?" - heck yeah, let's finally go - Sign up for a trial - um... - Requires a CC for a 30-day free trial Respectfully, this i…

Wow, that’s the same experience that I havr trying to use any app on the iOS App Store. Download, use one basic feature, use a second feature? Nope sign up first. Ok, signed up. Ok now? Nope, that feature requires a subscription. It is very sneaky because the app does not need to show in-app purchase on the App Store info. I have given up on Apps now because of this.

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#23
How do you guarantee you will not add GPL or similarly licensed code to my proprietary codebase? Microsoft committed to defending its customers from claims arising from CoPilot output [0]. Would you be confident enough to do likewise?

[0] https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/licensing/news/Microsoft-Cop...

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#24

- No details at all on the official extension page in VSCode - I bite the bullet and try anyway - No immediate confirmation after setup - Only one configuration option (log file path) - After I start typing into a buffer, the onboarding notification requires sign-in - Sure, why not - "Link to IDE?" - heck yeah, let's finally go - Sign up for a trial - um... - Requires a CC for a 30-day free trial Respectfully, this i…

Sorry. We should be more clear about the CC being required to sign up for the free trial.

I can understand the business imperatives (I am a PM at a start-up :)), but can you please make a decision on actually having the sign up flow work without friction (Think Slack / dropbox etc). You can always iterate and find the right thing to charge for but developers are a demanding bunch especially with tooling!

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#25

>At Supermaven we've developed and trained from scratch a new neural network architecture which is more efficient than a Transformer (the current standard architecture) at integrating information across a long context window. Clearly something proprietary, but in between this and Gemini's claimed 10M tokens, assuming there's no RAG... I'm curious what might be happening behind the scenes.

rope or ringattention?

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#26

- No details at all on the official extension page in VSCode - I bite the bullet and try anyway - No immediate confirmation after setup - Only one configuration option (log file path) - After I start typing into a buffer, the onboarding notification requires sign-in - Sure, why not - "Link to IDE?" - heck yeah, let's finally go - Sign up for a trial - um... - Requires a CC for a 30-day free trial Respectfully, this i…

Wow, that’s the same experience that I havr trying to use any app on the iOS App Store. Download, use one basic feature, use a second feature? Nope sign up first. Ok, signed up. Ok now? Nope, that feature requires a subscription. It is very sneaky because the app does not need to show in-app purchase on the App Store info. I have given up on Apps now because of this.

App developer here. Sadly, it’s what works. Put differently: when users browse for apps, it’s usually when their need for sth that solves the problem is relatively high. Which means you have a much higher chance of converting that user right now during onboarding than anytime later in the lifecycle of your app.

I wish Apple properly displayed prices though instead of this sneaky vague “contains in-app purchases” text.

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#27
>While a model like GPT-4 offers unmatched suggestion quality, it's impossible to run on every keystroke (unless you charge users $1,000/month)

Still alot less than the average SWE salary and this cost will go down over time.

Anyway, jokes aside, I usually don't use copilot tools in my IDEs. I have zero difficulty with coding itself. I would not enable one unless i'm trying to learn a new language or something. I can see how they would be helpful for more junior level engineers, but they'd still need someone senior to check for security vulnerabilities and the like.

Where LLMs come in handy is more complicated scenarios like understanding legacy spaghetti code, learning a new API without having to read the documentation, finding out how do to X in a new framework, undocumented behaviours and as a solo founder, non code tasks like marketing copy, mock customer interviews, writing data science type SQL queries to better understand my metrics, naming my subscription plans etc which I otherwise would not be that great at.

For these tasks I always use GPT-4 which almost always gets good results. But its nowhere near the level where it could replace an actual engineer, even if you fed it an entire codebase.

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#28

If you don’t like writing code, find a different line of work.

I really must be missing something with all of these tools writing code for you. Shipping my entire codebase off to some unknown party does not seem like a worthwhile tradeoff for not having to write my own indentation function or whatever.

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#29
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All the processing happens in the cloud. It will upload the git repository you use it on. We retain the data for a maximum of 7 days.

Your privacy policy[0] doesn't seem to mention any of this. How is the data being used? I'm not very certain about inputting my data into any tool that uploads to cloud and there's no valid privacy policy [0] https://supermaven.com/privacy-policy

> Our Services may contain links to third-party websites or services that are not owned or controlled by Supermaven, Inc. We are not responsible for the privacy practices or the content of third-party websites.

Is this actually good enough? Can companies just hand over data to other companies and then claim to not be responsible for the consequences of that?

Re: Show HN: Supermaven, the first code completion tool with 300k token context

#30
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your privacy policy[0] doesn't seem to mention any of this. How is the data being used? I'm not very certain about inputting my data into any tool that uploads to cloud and there's no valid privacy policy [0] https://supermaven.com/privacy-policy

We should update the site to be clearer about this. There is a 7-day data retention limit listed in https://supermaven.com/pricing .

Do you train and/or refine your models based on customer source code?
Post reply on HN