Live data from Hacker News

YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

youtube.com

71–80 of 90 posts

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#71
post #6

Life hack, maybe it will help someone out: Add a "before:YYYY" to the search to go back to a simpler time. Eg, "before:2012 python talk" As an experiment open two tabs and compare the results of "python talk" and "before:2012 python talk". The difference is staggering.

Also, 'sort by upload date' kills all the non directly keyword related results.

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#72

Everytime I use youtube search now I'm getting disgusting, sexualized recs when I search for a specific topic that is completely unrelated to that crap. I cannot even block these recommendations from the search result list, I cannot block these channels. Youtube/Google have simply become insane. You're at work, looking for some Youtube coding tutorial, and you get some video with a sexual thumbnail, or something abou…

If you have a 12 year old kid in the house then uhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#73

You know what else bothers me. If I hover over a thumbnail for a video, that now counts as a view and gets added to my history. Clogging up my feed with more algorithmic horseshit I don't want to watch. I'm thinking of just using nebula because I mostly watch science videos and I'm tired of the algo inserting shit I'm not the least bit interested in.

Just scrolling the frontpage on youtube mobile adds stuff randomly to your watch history, it seems to count anything you linger on - however briefly - as a 'watch'

Needless to say ten minutes of absentmindedly scrolling ruins your suggested results for a long time

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#75

youtube needs a competitor. i hate their products, i hate youtube music more. but i can't use something else.

YouTube has competitors, but none of them are very serious about the job. They're just kind of vibing in slightly-adjacent niches, afraid to take a bite at the top dog.

I'm not sure it's afraid but more the resources required to make it successful.

Bandwidth isn't cheap, storage is a bucket load and than moderation & copyright. Let alone any other issues.

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#76

So this doesn't even seem like an issue with search "quality" in a product sense -- it seems like something is actually deeply broken with YouTube search. This is a straight-up bug. For those not watching the video, he's searching for "games that think more gameplay mechanics equals more fun" (not in quotes) which you can see the results of: https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=games+that+thin... He expects i…

Its not a bug, its a choice. I remember this happened just after a big terrorist/insane person shooter attack. There was a graphic video from the shooting circulating on YT and instead of removing this clip and filtering uploads YT/Google decided to break search instead.

It might have been Christchurch mosque shooting videos.

Re: YouTube's search function is atrocious now [video]

#78

The most frustrating thing about youtube is how it's not smart enough to figure out that I want to watch "XX Part 55" after watching "XX Part 54". It just gives me random other videos on autoplay.

Absolutely -- this seriously seems like it should have been fixed years ago. And it's not like you need fancy AI to do it. Just a handful of simple heuristics.

It was already working years ago and they deliberately broke it
Post reply on HN