Live data from Hacker News

Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

twitter.com

161–170 of 472 posts

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#161
post #12

This is quite the loss for OpenAI. And no one seems to have heard what Ilya Sutskever's status is at OpenAI as well.

If I was Sam Altman, Ilya would be on a short leash. I’m actually amazed he wasn’t booted already.

He might be talented, but if he can’t be trusted, he needs to go.

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#162

Frankly, OpenAI seems to be losing its luster, and fast. Plugins were a failure. GPTs are a little better, but I still don't see the product market fit. GPT-4 is still king, but not by that much any more. It's not even clear that they're doing great research, because they don't publish. GPT-5 has to be incredibly good at this point, and I'm not sure that it will be.

Perhaps just me, but responses are way worse than it was few months ago. Now the system just makes shit up and says "Yes you are right" when you catch it on BS.

It is practically unusable and I'll likely cancel paid plan soon.

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#163

Let me say, he's a great teacher! I took a CV class with him. He should teach more, and take it seriously. Being a popular AI influencer is not necessarily correlated with being a good researcher though. And I would argue there is a strong indication that it is negatively correlated with being a good business leader / founder. Here's to hoping he chills out and goes back to the sorely needed lost art of explaining co…

Sometimes I wish as a profession we valued teaching more. I would love to teach, but not do research, and make a living.

Become the next 3blue1brown. He has inspired many.

Here's a gem of educator. Check out his other videos.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dhYqflvJMXc

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Examples? (I'm not that familiar with field.)

Andrej Karpathy is badmephisto, a name you might have heard of if you're into cubing. http://badmephisto.com/

I haven't been that surprised by something in a long time. Wow that is crazy. I made a little unfinished 3d Rubik's Cube site for fun a while back and the about section includes a link to his channel and some other older cubing channels. https://rubie-cubie.vercel.app/

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly I have more faith in hacker news users than congress.

I wish more of us would run for Congress. I'd much rather have a government of technocrats of various stripes than ex lawyers and rich business types. IMO governments, like websites, should be boring but effective, focused on small day to day improvements, not all flash and empty marketing chasing cultural trends...

Look into the Technocracy movement and why it failed.

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Honestly I have more faith in hacker news users than congress.

I wish more of us would run for Congress. I'd much rather have a government of technocrats of various stripes than ex lawyers and rich business types. IMO governments, like websites, should be boring but effective, focused on small day to day improvements, not all flash and empty marketing chasing cultural trends...

If you like this idea, read the Fifth Risk by Michael Lewis (he also wrote the Big Short which you may have seen). The book essentially argues that this is already the case in many (crucially not all) government departments. I like to TL;DR the book to other people as "the deep state is good, actually". Of course, the government itself is absolutely not helmed by technocratic politicians.

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#167

Unpopular opinion… but IMO almost all of Karpathy’s fame an influence come from being an incredible educator and communicator. Relative to his level of fame, his actual level of contribution as far as pushing forward AI, I’m not so sure about. I deeply appreciate his educational content and I’m glad that it has led to a way for him to gain influence and sustain a career. Hopefully he’s rich enough from that that he c…

Would have to agree. Looking at Karpathys research career it’s hard to pin point something and say he’s the inventor of so and so. There are plenty of other researchers for whol you can easily say he’s the inventor of so and so and they have much lesser fame than Karpathy, for example Kaiming He for ResNet, John Schulman for PPO etc.

I don’t see that as an issue though, just a natural consequence of his great work in teaching neural networks!

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#168
post #12

This is quite the loss for OpenAI. And no one seems to have heard what Ilya Sutskever's status is at OpenAI as well.

Frankly I consider every moment of silence from Ilya a reason to keep my expectations above the floor and I imagine a lot of people feel the same with how drunk on ai doomerism and gatekeeping Ilya was. The only downside to the silence is it gives him time to try and shake off the association between his name and that circus with the board.

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#169

Unpopular opinion… but IMO almost all of Karpathy’s fame an influence come from being an incredible educator and communicator. Relative to his level of fame, his actual level of contribution as far as pushing forward AI, I’m not so sure about. I deeply appreciate his educational content and I’m glad that it has led to a way for him to gain influence and sustain a career. Hopefully he’s rich enough from that that he c…

In 2015 he wrote this blog post about "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Recurrent Neural Networks": https://karpathy.github.io/2015/05/21/rnn-effectiveness/ That blog post inspired Alec Radford at Open AI to do the research that produced the "Unsupervised sentiment neuron": https://openai.com/research/unsupervised-sentiment-neuron Open AI decided to see what happened if they scaled up that model by leveraging the ne…

I read that post recently and it felt prescient to someone who has not been deeply involved in ML

Even the HN discussion around this had comments like "this feels my baby learning to speak.." which are the same comparisons people were saying when LLMs hit mainstream in 2022

Re: Hi everyone yes, I left OpenAI yesterday

#170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Examples? (I'm not that familiar with field.)

Andrej Karpathy is badmephisto, a name you might have heard of if you're into cubing. http://badmephisto.com/

Holy crap!! I never knew that. I watched this guy so much in 5th grade, he helped me get my 3x3 time down to 8 seconds.

This is insane

Post reply on HN