Live data from Hacker News

Tell HN: GitHub is blocking search unless you are logged in

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 76 posts

Re: Tell HN: GitHub is blocking search unless you are logged in

#51

It's unfortunate but it's not as bad as Twitter/other forced logins for features. The difference is that making an account is free, you don't have to pay anything and there are no ads, whereas Twitter has incentive because it needs ad revenue and wants to look like it has more people on it

> not as bad as Twitter

Can't help but feel that's what we're moving towards.

Re: Tell HN: GitHub is blocking search unless you are logged in

#52
Github was rate-limiting me from doing just basic searches. I hit them, paging through results too fast, and it times me out. My account is a few years old, but admittedly, it lacks engagement à la social media (favorites, repos, forks, etc).

Anyway, I don't buy Github's excuse that the new search 'takes more CPU power'; this must be to prevent scraping data for LLMs. Have you hit the new search rate limits?

Re: Tell HN: GitHub is blocking search unless you are logged in

#54
post #2

This has been the case since the new code search replaced the old one ~9 months ago. The new code search is more resource intensive so Github chose to only make it available to users. I agree that it sucks to not have code search available when logged out, but it's not a new change and I don't think it was done with malicious intent.

any requirement to log in is done with malicious intent.

what other purpose could it hold other than to harvest your data for their own undisclosed purposes?

Maybe anti-bots or something, but there are other ways to do that. Besides, a bot might just make an account.

Re: Tell HN: GitHub is blocking search unless you are logged in

#55
For several months now I refuse to stay logged in to Github. I login on an incognito window when I need something, and log out when I'm done. Github javascript is disabled outside of incognito windows.

This is the same playbook I have followed with success to disconnect from Facebook, Linkedin, Google, Reddit and Twitter. (And Quora. And Medium..) When it's inconvenient it just makes me try to avoid these sites.

Re: Tell HN: GitHub is blocking search unless you are logged in

#56
post #2

This has been the case since the new code search replaced the old one ~9 months ago. The new code search is more resource intensive so Github chose to only make it available to users. I agree that it sucks to not have code search available when logged out, but it's not a new change and I don't think it was done with malicious intent.

I don't actually care whether intent is malicious or not. GitHub has not cared about me or individual devs like me for some time now. Time to drop it.

Re: Tell HN: GitHub is blocking search unless you are logged in

#57
post #35

Despite their shitty rug-pull https://github.com/sourcegraph/sourcegraph/pull/53345 >, I do really like Sourcegraph and one doesn't (currently?!) need to be logged in to use it: https://sourcegraph.com/search and they have a handy rewrite pattern such that one can just plug the repo path into the URL for quick searching e.g. https://sourcegraph.com/github.com/JetBrains/intellij-commun...

Oh you better believe it's only currently. At least if they grow as successful as they would like to.

Re: Tell HN: GitHub is blocking search unless you are logged in

#59
post #38
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have my cookies autodeleted on a regular basis because I prefer my browsing sessions and activity to not be linked for surveillance purposes. The use of a password manager makes re-logging-in effortless.

I have a specific firefox container group for github and a few other applications so that it's not leaking cookies. No need to relogin.

GitHub still knows all of your individual visits to GitHub, and which repos you viewed. Most of the time I don’t want to be browsing GitHub itself whilst logged in. I don’t like or trust Microsoft with my location or waking hours or browsing history.
Post reply on HN