Live data from Hacker News

The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

androidpolice.com

101–110 of 130 posts

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#101

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Android scrolling wasn't bad enough for normal, non-picky users to notice. It's only techies who are used to iOS scrolling who complain about it.

> Android scrolling wasn't bad enough for normal, non-picky users to notice. To _notice_? Maybe not, but perhaps the price difference vs the iPhone was more important than the smooth scrolling?

Doesn't the iPhone 3GS sell for free and iPhone 4 for $99?

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#102
post #89
post #84

All I think about when I look at that phone is that it is yet another bland slab phone running Android. That form factor is really holding back handset design in my opinion, and I had high hopes that Samsung was going to do something really innovative with this device when they released that teaser video about how they were going to stand out from the crowd, but sadly not with this. Whatever about the input from the…

> Samsung is very conservative when it comes to design You might not have heard of the galaxy note then, or tell me your own definition of conservative.

What, you mean their re-invention of the PDA?

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#103
post #2

The community design is an "and", not an "or". The Galaxy Tab model which had issues with this in Germany, if you look at it, has all , not just one, of those characteristics. The "Apple thinks it owns the rectangle" meme is nice, but untrue. Nilay Patel, in the Verge article linked by Android Community: Now, some of these are a little ridiculous when taken individually — is Apple going to sue every digital photo fra…

The average human being is a complete imbecile. When they see any rectangular device that can make sounds and records sounds, they truly believe it is an iPhone. They're all like "whoa is that the new Iphone?". Really, regular people are complete idiots.

Calling them imbecile is a bit drastic but I've also seen ordinary people call any kind of smartphone an iPhone because they have no clue about this stuff. Same for MP3 players, which they call iPods. May be like calling any kind of vacuum cleaner a hoover.

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#104
post #2

The community design is an "and", not an "or". The Galaxy Tab model which had issues with this in Germany, if you look at it, has all , not just one, of those characteristics. The "Apple thinks it owns the rectangle" meme is nice, but untrue. Nilay Patel, in the Verge article linked by Android Community: Now, some of these are a little ridiculous when taken individually — is Apple going to sue every digital photo fra…

The average human being is a complete imbecile. When they see any rectangular device that can make sounds and records sounds, they truly believe it is an iPhone. They're all like "whoa is that the new Iphone?". Really, regular people are complete idiots.

Unlike you, who is prone to hysterical generalisations. Perhaps you ought to step outside and meet some other human beings rather than just looking at them on computer screens.

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#105
And all the fandroid hostility is precisely because this ugly device doesn't look like an iPhone. Smartphones were mostly ugly before Apple came into the market, now Apple have set the aesthetic standard and all the wannabes can do is copy it. Now the fandroids wet their panties bacause the plagiarists are sued for plagiarism.

EDIT erroneous reference to microphone icon removed

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#106
post #105

And all the fandroid hostility is precisely because this ugly device doesn't look like an iPhone. Smartphones were mostly ugly before Apple came into the market, now Apple have set the aesthetic standard and all the wannabes can do is copy it. Now the fandroids wet their panties bacause the plagiarists are sued for plagiarism. EDIT erroneous reference to microphone icon removed

You mean the microphone icon that's been Voice Search for a year before Apple's Siri came out?

http://googlemobile.blogspot.com/2010/08/just-speak-it-intro...

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#107
post #95
post #3

I'd have to disagree about it being an ugly design. What was ugly was the hack of putting squares around every icon, when those icons were designed to live on their own, not in a square. That's what was ugly. I'm happy to see the squares gone and the design conform to the standard Android design guidelines. The dock of icons going away is also good. If I'm looking in the applications list it's because I'm looking for…

Indeed, and actually, I like it (and I'm not one prone to like Android handset design). Especially in that shot with the three generations side by side. The first two mimic an iPhone 3G and an iPhone 4, and it shows, while the SIII really stands on its own (that's coming from someone who downright LOVES the iPhone 4 design). I wish they would have let go the metal on the side and went for a bit straighter lines on th…

I agree. I'm and iPhone user and I don't think the S3 looks bad at all. It actually looks kind of nice. More importantly it's distinct. It doesn't look like a fake iPhone.

Now I've never touched one.aybe in hand all that tapering feels weird. But it seems like a large improvement over the "pretend I'm an iPhone" look of the previous models.

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#109
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

that hasn't been true since long time now, especially so since ICS That's plain out wrong. I'm on a Galaxy Nexus with ICS. Scrolling and responsiveness are still major issues. In 2012 I expect my phone to respond instantly and scroll smoothly, in all but the most extra-ordinary situations. iOS demonstrates how it's done. On Android ICS my touches still incur a random lag that prevents me from tapping "by muscle memor…

I seriously don't know what you are complaining about. Bought my GNex straight from Google and it is hardware accelerated, is stock Android, had no bloat ware at all, all apps scroll butter smooth and there is no random lag or jerkiness. And I am not alone in liking GNex over the iPhone.

I have a Verizon GNex (got it 9am on launch day) and I don't see lag either.

Re: The Samsung Galaxy S III: The First Smartphone Designed Entirely By Lawyers

#110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Samsung made $10 billion over the last two quarters selling devices with outdated 2.x Android software. And last time I checked my carriers, none of their myriad of Samsung devices came with ICS. Clearly ICS and smooth scrolling is not important to the carriers or their typical customers. Consequently, ICS is not important to Samsung. It's not ignorant to say that Andriod scrolls poorly. It's just that scrolling perf…

> And last time I checked my carriers, none of their myriad of Samsung devices came with ICS I don't know which carriers you checked, but the Samsung Galaxy Nexus (which runs stock ICS) has been on the market for several months now. In the US, it's available from Verizon, AT&T, and Sprint.

I don't think you can consider the Galaxy Nexus a Samsung phone. Yes, it's built by Samsung, but they're more a contractor for Google in this case.

The Galaxy S II and its differing variants in the US all still run Android 2.3, with only promises that they might eventually get an update.

Post reply on HN