Live data from Hacker News

A rural ski slope caught up in an international scam

newyorker.com

1–10 of 62 posts

Re: A rural ski slope caught up in an international scam

#4
post #3

EB-5 is just a way to buy a green card. The US government should cut out all of these middlemen with dubious “investment opportunities” and just have the money go straight to the federal budget.

Can't do it. If you try to change it people will say "The US is up for sale to the highest bidder" and you'll get run out of office. It's fortunate it even exists. Best not to mess with this stuff.

Re: A rural ski slope caught up in an international scam

#5
I live and ski in this area[0]. Have season's passes to Burke Mountain and even met Stenger and Quiros back when they were running the ski areas.

On the slopes, at my coworking space, and around the campfire in the Summer, the topic of how to make this little pocket of Northeast Vermont more economically viable is a topic that comes up often.

I'm starting to form an opinion that we shouldn't try to compete, at any level, with larger job centers. We lost a huge (per capita, it was never large in total dollar values) number of manufacturing jobs over the past 20 years. That's not coming back. Perhaps there's a niche for us, and other rural communities in creating a great place for people to live and work remotely. Funding co-working spaces and high speed internet is a lot easier than getting a manufacturer to move in given that we have a tiny labor market.

Bigger issues for getting any population growth is our perverse tax and housing regulations. Not going to go into them in depth here but we have a water protection act that adds 10-20% to any construction project near water and wetlands even if the area already has a lot of development. Besides making things more expensive, it also encourages sprawl since many communities are built near water but it's cheaper to build in the hills surrounding them away from wetlands. One of the only ways to make a real estate investment pay off up here is to buy a plot, subdivide into 3 acre lots, put in a road and electricity and sell housing lots. The hassle of dealing with Act 250 doesn't make it worth it to do the actual development and so you don't see it. The only developments in my area are either 40 years old or the aforementioned building lots.

We also have an aging and decrepit housing stock and the tax structure for capital gains strongly penalizes flipping houses which is an accelerator on updating housing inventory. Instead, housing investment, like many places, is solely in short term rental or buy and hold/rent.

[0] https://northeastkingdom.com/

Re: A rural ski slope caught up in an international scam

#7
> The whole program, it turned out, lent itself to dishonesty. Faraway investors were desperate to get to the U.S., and didn’t keep close track of where their money was going. The lawyers and brokers got large transaction fees and had little incentive to point out potential wrongdoing. “Everybody was making millions of dollars, but very few people wanted to speak the truth about the riskiness of these investments,” Gibson, the EB-5 adviser, said. There was almost no governmental oversight built in.

Tale as old as time. Whenever the government simply funnels money out to "businesses" without oversight, it's going to get embezzled. The massive fraud that came along for the ride with PPP COVID relief is just the latest example. The government never seems to learn though, and I'm sure in 2-5 more years, there will be another money firehose and along with it the predictable fraud.

Funny how when it comes to handing money out to low income individuals, the government is willing to spend $100 for every $1 handed out: to scrutinize, means-test, and put these payments under a microscope of enforced rules. But when it comes to handing money out to rich people and businesses, all of a sudden "there's no way we can oversee such a complex program!"

Re: A rural ski slope caught up in an international scam

#8

I live and ski in this area[0]. Have season's passes to Burke Mountain and even met Stenger and Quiros back when they were running the ski areas. On the slopes, at my coworking space, and around the campfire in the Summer, the topic of how to make this little pocket of Northeast Vermont more economically viable is a topic that comes up often. I'm starting to form an opinion that we shouldn't try to compete, at any le…

> On the slopes, at my coworking space, and around the campfire in the Summer

Your answer is pretty much right there. Make the ski resort into a world-class apres-ski destination that many people would love to live around that environment or visit on the weekends from the Montreal metro of 4.3m or Boston CSA of 8.5m people. Then you'll have the second-order effects of buses, coworking places, cafes, restaurants, and breweries.

Re: A rural ski slope caught up in an international scam

#9

> The whole program, it turned out, lent itself to dishonesty. Faraway investors were desperate to get to the U.S., and didn’t keep close track of where their money was going. The lawyers and brokers got large transaction fees and had little incentive to point out potential wrongdoing. “Everybody was making millions of dollars, but very few people wanted to speak the truth about the riskiness of these investments,” G…

Usually the government is fully aware of the risks of fraud.

But that the cost of not implementing the program is far worse.

Which in the case of PPP would've meant a lot of businesses failing and workers without a job.

Post reply on HN