Live data from Hacker News

How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent

adaobi.substack.com

21–30 of 225 posts

Re: How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent

#21

Summary of the text: "How to herd a heard of nerds?"

Given how people on HN think they're so smart I'm surprised this article got voted up. Usually it's some article about how high IQ correlates with people who drink water. They just vote up the article for self validation.

Now it's an article for the Narutos of the world. Guess a good number of people think they're stupid. I think both sides are wrong.

Re: How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent

#22
post #3

“Most people who are talented or smart are scared of doing things” I have noticed this a lot in my career, I think it’s because these people self identify as smart/talented and every time you attempt some task, there is the possibility of failure - and for the “smart” person, failing at a task takes a stab at the heart of their identity. Self cushioning in a cloud of rationales “well, I can’t do X but at least I’m sm…

> for the “smart” person, failing at a task takes a stab at the heart of their identity. Self cushioning in a cloud of rationales “well, I can’t do X but at least I’m smart” means that if “being smart” is ever questioned, the possibility of them failing terrifies them.

Yes, I see it much the same way. If you're curious, I wrote about a related theme a few years ago here [1].

> When the work is uncertain, she withers: uncertainty means the unknown, which means risk, which means failure, which means she's worthless. The thought of fumbling in the void terrifies her.

[1]: https://arunkprasad.com/log/unlearning-perfectionism/

Re: How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent

#23

I think the writer just suffers a huge case of imposter syndrome! Most seemingly 'smart' and 'talented' people are just people who know that 'Hard work beats talent when talent fails to work hard'

I’m pretty sure the entire premise is more than a little facetious, and the author already knows this.

Re: How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent

#24
post #3

“Most people who are talented or smart are scared of doing things” I have noticed this a lot in my career, I think it’s because these people self identify as smart/talented and every time you attempt some task, there is the possibility of failure - and for the “smart” person, failing at a task takes a stab at the heart of their identity. Self cushioning in a cloud of rationales “well, I can’t do X but at least I’m sm…

As one of those 'naturally smart' types, part of the trouble there for me is that everything is easy right up until it isn't. I was well into college before I ever had to actually study or prepare or do second drafts on anything at all to succeed, and for obvious reasons I sucked at it and crashed and burned completely with several subjects before I got any kind of grip on things.

The good news is that addressing this kind of thing is the hot topic in gifted education, and has been for some time. The “I suddenly got very dumb” story’s nigh-universality has been noticed, and they’re working on fixing it.

The bad news is that you may have been too early for that. Well, and also that I’m not sure how effective efforts to address it have actually been.

Re: How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent

#25

I'd add only one thing: Be the person that solves problems. Employers want people that can solve their problems. they may not even care how it gets solved... as long as they problem they have will get solved so they can move forward. Often this takes talent and skill, but in my live I've found that sheer bloody minded persistence and doing things the hard way will often be exactly what is needed and appreciated.

The ability to encourage others/organise and cut through the ‘swamp’. Is it intelligence? Absolute intelligence measured by results, not by IQ.

Re: How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent

#27

Some of the author's other articles are worth reading as well. I read them instead of focusing on work and 100% don't regret it.

Hey no kidding, some pretty insightful stuff in their more newsletter/blog-y posts. Their medical research is way over my head but also seems extremely cool.

Thanks for the rec!

Re: How to do things if you're not that smart and don't have any talent

#29

I'd add only one thing: Be the person that solves problems. Employers want people that can solve their problems. they may not even care how it gets solved... as long as they problem they have will get solved so they can move forward. Often this takes talent and skill, but in my live I've found that sheer bloody minded persistence and doing things the hard way will often be exactly what is needed and appreciated.

Maybe also "be the one who understands the problem." Often times the problem that actually needs to be solved may be simpler than the problem you're tasked with solving, and being a small-brained person can help you from getting bogged down in unnecessary complexities.
Post reply on HN