Live data from Hacker News

I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

twitter.com

131–140 of 269 posts

Re: I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

#131

As someone who has played a lot of chess I don't find this useful. I'm surprised how many people have positive responses to this.

Consider for a moment the billions of people who have not played a lot of chess. Seems like a cool teaching aid for youngsters especially.

Re: I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

#132
post #131

As someone who has played a lot of chess I don't find this useful. I'm surprised how many people have positive responses to this.

Consider for a moment the billions of people who have not played a lot of chess. Seems like a cool teaching aid for youngsters especially.

Does it take anyone longer than a game or two to remember the rules of chess? I even taught chess to adults as a child and they caught on within a few moves. Which I guess explains why it remains more popular than FOTM overcomplicated board game #5000. It's not difficult to memorize. IMO this is a solution to a nonexistent problem.

Re: I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

#133
post #110

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wouldn’t it look like four capital tees joined at opposites/right angles at the stem?

I mean, sorta? If you think about it as the "rules of the move," but the actual movement can be drawn as a straight line. See: https://twitter.com/graycrawford/status/1750248031784763639

Ahhh, yes, from that pov, yes totally!

Re: I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

#134
post #132
post #131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Consider for a moment the billions of people who have not played a lot of chess. Seems like a cool teaching aid for youngsters especially.

Does it take anyone longer than a game or two to remember the rules of chess? I even taught chess to adults as a child and they caught on within a few moves. Which I guess explains why it remains more popular than FOTM overcomplicated board game #5000. It's not difficult to memorize. IMO this is a solution to a nonexistent problem.

Knowing the rules and 'seeing' the ways that pieces can move are different things. I could see this being helpful to someone who has a working knowledge of the ways pieces can move, but hasn't yet built their skill of visualization thereof.

Re: I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

#135
I hardly even play chess, but I do know the rules and how the pieces move, but this wrecks my intuitive sense of how the pieces move entirely, so I think it’d be a hard transition to regular pieces, which kind of kills any supposed benefit.

Re: I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

#136

For me the most surprising observation from this thread is this tweet [1] showing that the knight's moves are exactly the squares that the queen can't get to within a 2 square manhattan distance. I.e. the knight is an anti-queen. [1]: https://twitter.com/skidbladnirr_/status/1750285122769957129

Yup that's how they designed it in hexagonal chess: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hexagonal_chess#Rules

"the knight may move to any nearest cell not on an orthogonal or diagonal line on which it stands"

Re: I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

#138
post #52

I think this is fun, but (a) knights' threats are disconnected and this "flower" approach while good is maybe not ideal. You might as well use a hollow circle at that point. (b) when we say "chess pieces can be redesigned to be..." then I think about actual physical pieces, it would not do to make these as actual physical pieces because an accidental misplacement turns a rook into a bishop or vice versa. Gotta make t…

A swastika shape would make sense for the knight. I guess there is still a cultural aversion to its use, however.

A swastika?! Not quite, it's more like a cross: ꖅ

Re: I realized chess pieces can be redesigned to be geometric attack directions

#140

I prefer this: https://www.moma.org/collection/works/4746 The pieces resemble the movements in most cases, but also pack together into a rectangle.

> The pieces resemble the movements in most cases

I don't see it. Do they really?

Post reply on HN