Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

qwertle.friedman.in

11–20 of 65 posts

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#11
post #3

I would recommend that you have a gauge next to the play board with the colors and what they mean, ranked from close to far, so it's easy to understand. I actually took bright red to be closer to the answer then dim red/black, so I totally wiffed on the answer. Having that info on the play area would help prevent that mistake.

That's why I added the examples with descriptions, but I can understand if they were unclear. I can add a gauge to the game board, thanks for the recommendation

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#12
Cool idea (and great name). I use 'STEAL' as my first word in wordle. Wondering what a good starting word would be in this variant. First thought: something distributed equidistantly across the keyboard, second thought: aim for edges so you can rule out movement in some directions and reduce search complexity.

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#13
post #4

Please don’t use green and red like this, especially with multiple shades of red. It’s a nightmare for colorblind people.

Thanks for the feedback. I thought about colorblindness and figured it wouldn't matter since the important part is the brightness, not the hue. Is that not the case? But anyway that said I'm now kicking myself for not realizing that that doesn't help with differentiating the green for correct... any ideas on how to address this?

Try to pick more intuitive colours if possible. My first guess had both dark and bright red, and I wasn't sure which were closer/farther (had to reopen the site in incognito to get and read the instructions again). A more intuitive gradient (perhaps between just two colours, e.g. white and red) would remove the need for instructions.

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#15
post #2

Your game just told me "Ponzi" isn't a word. I feel like Wordle wouldn't have done that, and anyway at least it has the courtesy to say "not in word list" which is very different from the outright lie that your game just told me.

Yes it would: https://wordledictionary.com/results?find=_____&has=i,n,o,p,...

Ponzi is a surname, and not included in Wordle.

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#16
post #4

Please don’t use green and red like this, especially with multiple shades of red. It’s a nightmare for colorblind people.

Thanks for the feedback. I thought about colorblindness and figured it wouldn't matter since the important part is the brightness, not the hue. Is that not the case? But anyway that said I'm now kicking myself for not realizing that that doesn't help with differentiating the green for correct... any ideas on how to address this?

Maybe use a different color altogether for correct letters, like blue or bright yellow?

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#17
I like it! It would be nice if you could tap on any of the letters you have already typed when you are entering a guess and be able to see the guesses for that letter and change that letter without having to delete the other letters as you are working on a guess, I also agree with some of the feedback on making the color scale clearer.

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#18
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks for the feedback. I thought about colorblindness and figured it wouldn't matter since the important part is the brightness, not the hue. Is that not the case? But anyway that said I'm now kicking myself for not realizing that that doesn't help with differentiating the green for correct... any ideas on how to address this?

Try to pick more intuitive colours if possible. My first guess had both dark and bright red, and I wasn't sure which were closer/farther (had to reopen the site in incognito to get and read the instructions again). A more intuitive gradient (perhaps between just two colours, e.g. white and red) would remove the need for instructions.

You can tap the question mark in the top left to see the instructions again! But yeah, I can see how the color scheme might be confusing. As Kluggy suggested, I might add a gauge on the side of the board which should help prevent that mistake

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#19
post #12

Cool idea (and great name). I use 'STEAL' as my first word in wordle. Wondering what a good starting word would be in this variant. First thought: something distributed equidistantly across the keyboard, second thought: aim for edges so you can rule out movement in some directions and reduce search complexity.

I always start with FRUIT, no idea if it's optimal but it works pretty well. Also, unlike Wordle, there's no downside to guessing words with repeated letters, so something like FLUFF could probably work too

Re: Show HN: Qwertle, yet another daily word game

#20
Perhaps it is intended that players figure it out for themselves, but it would help to be more clear about which distances correspond to which color. And apparently being adjacent on the next row is not "as close" as being adjacent on the same row. I had assumed that there would be an equal radius covering the same color.
Post reply on HN