Live data from Hacker News

Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

extremetech.com

21–30 of 38 posts

Re: Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

#21

I don't really see that this has much to do with the Raspberry Pi. If the board without the (much more powerful) CPU alone is $100, it's not really comparable other than being relatively small.

My first thought was "watch out bicycle makers, other people are making cars".

The RasPi is a disposable learning and tinkering board like an arduino. This Intel thing is just a laptop without a screen. Genuinely nothing to see here.

Re: Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

#22
post #8

The author of this article clearly has no idea about what a system like Raspberry Pi is aiming for. The lack of Windows compatibility is one of its most important features. It's about kids learning to do fun, interesting, challenging things with a computer. It's not about using an office suite or playing TF2.

You could install Linux on the NUC, too. x86 support isn't inherently a bad thing, surely.

No, not at all. It's just that statements like "and likewise, developing for the NUC will be as easy as developing for a standard, Windows-based x86 PC; two perks the Raspberry Pi will not enjoy." makes it seem like a lack of x86 support is a bad thing in the Pi's case, which it's not, since ARM is fine for what it's meant to do.

As for the part about development being as easy as a Windows x86 box; the same could be said about Linux on the Raspberry Pi. It's the same OS you'd run on an x86 box.

Just seems like an apples/oranges comparison. Like others have commented, seems like a lot of 'tech journalists' seem to assume small form factor == Raspberry Pi competitor/alternative.

Re: Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

#23
That's great, although they're not a competitor to Raspberry. Speculation on the author's part aside, I can't imagine Intel offering this anywhere near a $100 price point. But without the comparison offered up by the author, it's just another tiny-motherboard-from-Intel article -- and who's going to read that?

But hey, I hope they try to compete with Raspberry Pi, because that causes a race to the bottom of the price point. Since Raspberry is already there, anyone else who wants to join the party just adds more options to those interested in these devices.

Re: Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

#24
post #8

The author of this article clearly has no idea about what a system like Raspberry Pi is aiming for. The lack of Windows compatibility is one of its most important features. It's about kids learning to do fun, interesting, challenging things with a computer. It's not about using an office suite or playing TF2.

David Braben:

it’s a small PC. There’s nothing really you can’t do with this that you couldn’t do with a PC from way back. We can run things like OpenOffice, Twitter, browse the web, Facebook etc

http://www.edge-online.com/features/david-braben-interview

Re: Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

#25
post #9

I don't really see that this has much to do with the Raspberry Pi. If the board without the (much more powerful) CPU alone is $100, it's not really comparable other than being relatively small.

30 times the power consumption. 7 times the cost (you probably wanted a CPU and RAM to go with the motherboard). No programmable pins for controlling the world. Closed design. It's just a tiny PC motherboard. Nothing to do with a Raspberry Pi other than the hook Sebastian Anthony chose for his title.

Isn't Raspberry Pi also pretty much a proprietary design? Certainly the Broadcom chipset they use isn't available to the general public, nor is information about the chipset available without an NDA.

Re: Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

#26
Personally, I'm actually more excited about this than the Raspberry Pi. Yes it consumes more power and is basically just a small PC, but that's actually what I'm more interested in for pc-tv development. The fact that it could run Windows too is actually a plus.

Re: Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

#29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You could install Linux on the NUC, too. x86 support isn't inherently a bad thing, surely.

No, not at all. It's just that statements like "and likewise, developing for the NUC will be as easy as developing for a standard, Windows-based x86 PC; two perks the Raspberry Pi will not enjoy." makes it seem like a lack of x86 support is a bad thing in the Pi's case, which it's not, since ARM is fine for what it's meant to do. As for the part about development being as easy as a Windows x86 box; the same could be…

Besides the price of Windows would be too high for it.

Re: Watch out, Raspberry Pi: Intel unveils ultra-small Next Unit of Computing PC

#30
post #14

Although in no way a competitor to the rPi, this is pretty awesome. It could easily become a main system with surprisingly few compromises-- (given thunderbolt and the reasonable iGPU)... and i really doubt the board alone will be available for < $200.

there is nothing reasonable about igpu

tell me about opengl drivers

tellll meeeeeeeee

Post reply on HN