Live data from Hacker News

Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

reuters.com

91–100 of 217 posts

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#91
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are there places where eating plastics is considered a normal food or food additive?

Plastic pens Plastic straws Plastic Lilly sticks Plastic tie-wraps Basically anything that someone might chew on! Although, licorice roots are okay to chew on... I guess. :-)

> Although, licorice roots are okay to chew on... I guess.

Licorice can be toxic: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8962506/

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#92
post #64
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How many cycles do we have to go through of "oh, recklessly dumping this substance into the ecosystem probably doesn't have any ill effects, and you should prove it does before being such a negative nelly"? Just once, I'd like to sacrifice consumerism at the altar of my and my family's internal organs, versus the other way around. We're a few decades late to finally be putting full product lifecycle accountability in…

> How many cycles do we have to go through of "oh, recklessly dumping this substance into the ecosystem probably doesn't have any ill effects, and you should prove it does before being such a negative nelly"? Because to be blunt, and even to adopt your inflammatory frame, "recklessly dumping substances into the ecosystem" has been Generally Accepted As Safe for literally thousands of years. For everything particular…

> "recklessly dumping substances into the ecosystem" has been Generally Accepted As Safe for literally thousands of years.

For hundreds of thousands, substances that have negative effects (eg human corpses) were disposed of far from populations, precisely because humans learned that consequences quickly. Humans have been cognizant of causation, when they could detect it, for longer than thousands of years. Yes the black plague took awhile to figure out. As we saw with cigarettes, society is always trending to keeping the status quo. Often, to society's own detriment over the short term, along the span of human existence.

> We have 8 billion of us out there, demanding zero impact just isn't going to happen.

That's not relevant.

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#93
post #36

It's time to come up with what I'd call a Plastic Chain Index. For any given edible item, a very low plastic chain index implies that it would only have plastic inadvertently absorbed from the environment, whereas a high one would be e.g. those super hot French fries rolling in plastic. If you're optimistic, this will usher in easy measurement, widespread awareness and consumer enlightenment. But realistically, we wi…

What are super hot french fries rolling in plastic? You mean like ready meals that you heat up in plastic containers?

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#94
I firmly believe the only way to stop our culture from obsessing over the wrong things (politics, climate emergency, vaccines) is to give it something even worse to focus on - enter the War on Plastic! I genuinely hope this catches on and people start putting anti-plastic flags on their lawns.

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#95
post #74

How much should we worry about the disposable cups they put coffee in? My understanding is we’re putting a hot liquid in a cup lined with plastic.

All canned drinks are lined with plastics. I think all canned things, period, at this point.

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#96

Note that they seem to only appear in processed food. That's kind of OK of you cook yourself apparently.

That's not true, they gave examples of raw meats (and how they were packed):

Perdue Ground Chicken Breast (foam tray with plastic wrap) 9,985

Trader Joe’s Ground Pork 80% Lean 20% Fat (plastic wrap) 5,503

Stop & Shop Ground Beef 80% Lean 20% Fat (paperboard with plastic wrap) 2,729

And dairy:

Tuscan Dairy Farms Whole Milk (plastic) 10,932

Land O’Lakes Butter Salted (paper wrap/cardboard) 581

These numbers are much lower than some of the others, but they are not only in processed food.

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#97
post #36

It's time to come up with what I'd call a Plastic Chain Index. For any given edible item, a very low plastic chain index implies that it would only have plastic inadvertently absorbed from the environment, whereas a high one would be e.g. those super hot French fries rolling in plastic. If you're optimistic, this will usher in easy measurement, widespread awareness and consumer enlightenment. But realistically, we wi…

this is a fine idea in theory, but in practice, the responsibility for managing such an index would (in the US) be split unpredictably between the FDA and/or USDA. the agencies have wildly varying budgets, a Byzantine web of overlap in their responsibilities, and the GOP's trying to defund them both anyway.

indeed, the Supreme Court's agreed to hear a case next year which they may use to dismantle the entire legal basis for all the US govmt's regulatory agencies. arguments in that case begin on Jan 17th

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#98
post #95
post #74

How much should we worry about the disposable cups they put coffee in? My understanding is we’re putting a hot liquid in a cup lined with plastic.

All canned drinks are lined with plastics. I think all canned things, period, at this point.

nope, phthalate-free cans have been a selling point for a while now. standard for canned beans at Sprouts or Whole Foods

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#99
post #19

Earlier quoted context omitted.

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20230103-how-plastic-is-g... > Plastic particles can also contaminate food crops directly. A 2020 study found microplastics and nanoplastics in fruit and vegetables sold by supermarkets and in produce sold by local sellers in Catania in Sicily, Italy. Apples were the most contaminated fruit, and carrots had the highest levels of microplastics among the sampled vegetables. > Accordin…

Isn't there also limited to no evidence of harms from these in humans?

Isn't there also limited to no evidence of harms from these in humans?

nope, tons of evidence of harm

Re: Consumer Reports finds 'widespread' presence of plastics in food

#100

Note that they seem to only appear in processed food. That's kind of OK of you cook yourself apparently.

CR only tested processed food so that's not really a conclusion you can make.

easily disproven by reading the orignal Consumer Reports post (as opposed to the Reuters article that this thread links to)

https://www.consumerreports.org/health/food-contaminants/the...

Post reply on HN