Live data from Hacker News

Firefox Sync actually works

howtogeek.com

31–40 of 343 posts

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#31
post #2

(Sorry for title editing; HN cuts of "The Best" if a title starts with that, which would make for a rather nonsensical title...)

This makes me wonder how much of moderation (and thus headline editing) could be done by an LLM, and if that would be an overall improvement.

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#32

I've avoided FF sync because I don't want my browser history on the cloud. I only really want my profile configuration, such as my addons and userjs flags. Unfortunately the FF directory in my .config is intermixed enough between config and content that I don't try to back it up. Am I missing something?

You can turn history sync off. It’s like, one of the first main toggle options shown to the user.

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#33

Firefox on iOS randomly changes the order of new bookmarks, adding new ones to either the top or the bottom of the list. I assume they're assuming ordering in some underlying platform data structure that doesn't support it? EDIT: I guess it was this, though I think it's been broken again more recently? https://github.com/mozilla-mobile/firefox-ios/pull/11895 At any rate I've found Firefox on iOS/iPadOS to be surprisi…

Firefox on ios is just a reskin of Safari. They would need extra effort to make the account system work on that

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#34
See "Chrome Sync privacy is still very bad"[1] and its predecessor article[2] about Chrome and Firefox for an evaluation of the privacy and security of browser syncing.

[1] https://palant.info/2023/08/29/chrome-sync-privacy-is-still-...

[2] https://palant.info/2018/03/13/can-chrome-sync-or-firefox-sy...

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#35
post #20

Configuring browsers to mirror each other across machines makes a big soupy mess. I understand why surveillance capitalists like the idea, makes their lives a little easier. But I really don't get why I'm supposed to want it. I use different machines differently. The laptop I'm typing this on is my "main" browser, I have lots of bookmarks set up in a specific structure. I only use my phone browser when I have to, and…

Shoutout to the time I was looking at job listings on my cellphone, which then immediately popped up on my work computer in front of my coworkers. I didn't even know there _was_ a sync feature, it got turned on automatically after an update. Fun.

No sync please.

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#36
post #28

I've avoided FF sync because I don't want my browser history on the cloud. I only really want my profile configuration, such as my addons and userjs flags. Unfortunately the FF directory in my .config is intermixed enough between config and content that I don't try to back it up. Am I missing something?

The sync contents are encrypted between devices. EDIT: After writing this, I realized I should investigate the claim, because new devices are added just by logging in, not by giving them any sort of password.

Yes, E2EE.

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#37

Firefox has grown on me since Google's war on ad blockers made me feel like it's "their" browser not mine. (Which is true ofc. But still.)

Same. I've tried to switch from a chromium based browser to FF several times over the last several years, and I always found something that was a deal breaker. A few months ago when the Google war on adblockers really started gaining steam, I tried the switch again, and it's been flawless, and I haven't found any good reasons not to use FF. It's been my default browser for at least two months now, and if it weren't for wanting web-usb for a few devices, I wouldn't even have a chromium based browser installed.

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#38
post #20

Configuring browsers to mirror each other across machines makes a big soupy mess. I understand why surveillance capitalists like the idea, makes their lives a little easier. But I really don't get why I'm supposed to want it. I use different machines differently. The laptop I'm typing this on is my "main" browser, I have lots of bookmarks set up in a specific structure. I only use my phone browser when I have to, and…

surprise revelation: some people work differently from you

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#39

I've avoided FF sync because I don't want my browser history on the cloud. I only really want my profile configuration, such as my addons and userjs flags. Unfortunately the FF directory in my .config is intermixed enough between config and content that I don't try to back it up. Am I missing something?

You can selfhost the sync server

Re: Firefox Sync actually works

#40
post #36
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The sync contents are encrypted between devices. EDIT: After writing this, I realized I should investigate the claim, because new devices are added just by logging in, not by giving them any sort of password.

Yes, E2EE.

The parent raised a good point tho. If you can add devices without entering encryption info, how can it be properly E2E?
Post reply on HN