Live data from Hacker News

Flipboard Begins to Federate

flipboard.medium.com

121–123 of 123 posts

Re: Flipboard Begins to Federate

#121
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Embrace isn't the time to worry, Extend is, and then only conditionally. If they come up with sensible features, then maybe the standard should evolve. But if it starts becoming too complex to implement or gives too much power to Meta, then I'm ready to join you in raising the alarm.

Just one quick question, can you point out an example where that worked?

HTTP. Many features have been added at the behest of big tech, but the core HTTP/1.1 protocol remains compatible with nearly all major software.

Note that this is a counterpoint to web browser protocols (especially CSS and JS), which Google has managed to extend to the point where they are now nearly the only viable browser engine vendor. They don't need to extinguish it because they completely control it.

Re: Flipboard Begins to Federate

#122
post #119

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not a paywall, it's a "member-only" story, hence a login wall.

I'm not sure where the disconnect is. What do you think the difference is? I don't see one. Membership requires payment, hence it is a paywall. Also, there is no paywall or membership wall on this story that I submitted.

It’s baffling that the CEO of Medium doesn’t know how their product works from the outside. Perhaps logging out of the website would reveal the full-page login-wall pop-ups on this article, as others in this thread have pointed out.

Re: Flipboard Begins to Federate

#123
post #122

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure where the disconnect is. What do you think the difference is? I don't see one. Membership requires payment, hence it is a paywall. Also, there is no paywall or membership wall on this story that I submitted.

It’s baffling that the CEO of Medium doesn’t know how their product works from the outside. Perhaps logging out of the website would reveal the full-page login-wall pop-ups on this article, as others in this thread have pointed out.

Thanks for explaining and being specific. I did do that when this thread started, opening the article in an incognito window. It’s a modal. Dismiss it.
Post reply on HN