Live data from Hacker News

Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

lunduke.com

1–10 of 100 posts

Re: Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

#2

  > The short version: Ubuntu 12.04 is the best release they’ve ever had and 
  > absolutely blows the upcoming releases of Windows and MacOS X out of the
  > water in just about every way that matters.
The second half of that statement may be a touch hyperbolic.

Re: Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

#3

> The short version: Ubuntu 12.04 is the best release they’ve ever had and > absolutely blows the upcoming releases of Windows and MacOS X out of the > water in just about every way that matters. The second half of that statement may be a touch hyperbolic.

It really seems to be a great release, but that second half clearly shows that kool aid comes in different flavors, not just apples :D

Re: Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

#4
I've tried the beta of 12.04 the past few weeks. Unity is still a pile of ----. Gnome Shell (3) isn't much better and fall back mode (Gnome Classic) is riddled with bugs that basically makes it unusable as a desktop to work on. The Linux desktop has finally officially failed.

Re: Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

#5
I've also tried beta 12.04, seems ok, but article is a really bit hyperbolic. IMO this ubuntu has similar progress from previous version as other versions in the past.

Big surprise for me: I've upgraded 4 years old laptop with new SSD disk and 12.04beta and its really lightning fast compared to windows 7 (altough I have to switch to Unity 2D because of too hot gpu). It really feels like new machine.

Re: Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

#7
When i tried out the 12.04 beta on my HP Microserver, installation went smoothly. However when booting up the installed system, all i'd get is a blank screen. Turns out for some odd reason it doesn't set the textmode display correctly, so you need to add a cryptic line to the boot options to see anything. Upon doing this, i found it was throwing a fit at a degraded raid array on a disk i happened to have plugged in at the time, and so wouldn't continue booting until i entered the emergency console and typed exit.

Certainly not the distro i'm looking for.

Re: Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

#8
post #4

I've tried the beta of 12.04 the past few weeks. Unity is still a pile of ----. Gnome Shell (3) isn't much better and fall back mode (Gnome Classic) is riddled with bugs that basically makes it unusable as a desktop to work on. The Linux desktop has finally officially failed.

As an effort to make this conversation productive for all involved: could you name a couple of these bugs in Gnome Classic?

Re: Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

#9
post #4

I've tried the beta of 12.04 the past few weeks. Unity is still a pile of ----. Gnome Shell (3) isn't much better and fall back mode (Gnome Classic) is riddled with bugs that basically makes it unusable as a desktop to work on. The Linux desktop has finally officially failed.

I am using Xfce as a desktop since Unity/G3 came out and made working on my netbook impossible. Xfce is quite fast and works mostly very good.

Re: Ubuntu 12.04 Review: This is the Distro you’re looking for.

#10
Unity and gnome-shell might be OK on a netbook. Or a notebook. Or maybe on a single monitor desktop.

For a triplehead setup this concept is just not bearable. I think this really bad design-decision goes back to the days when there was this "Linux the great netbook / eee-PC OS hype".

The good thing is: Nobody is forced to use this . There is Mate (http://mate-desktop.org/), or KDE, or XFCE, or ...

The only thing that I find a bit pity, is that so many resources are spent on Gnome3 and Unity :-/

Post reply on HN