Live data from Hacker News

BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

iflscience.com

171–180 of 208 posts

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#171

I did a PhD in brain-computer interfaces, including EEG and implanted electrodes. BCI research to a big extent focuses on helping paralyzed individuals regain communication. Unfortunately, EEG doesn’t provide sufficient signal-to-noise ratio to support good communication speeds outside of the lab with Faraday cages and days/weeks of de-noising including removing eye-movement artifacts in the recordings. This is a phy…

Recently, a Swiss-French team made the communication between the brain and the legs possible, and the device looked relatively mature. I think patient had nerves damaged in the vertebral column. What do you think about it ? Looked like a promising development. https://actu.epfl.ch/news/thought-controlled-walking-again-a...

Not OP, but Ttat article's use of the word "implant" implies a much more invasive device, which means a way better signal. Additionally, the output, while still complex, is far from the level of decoding of thought presented here. Thus, while still impressive, it is less of a leap from existing technology, and much more within the realm of what we know is very much possible.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#172
I'm a bit confused by the eavesdropping on thoughts conclusions being drawn. Did I misinterpret something, or wouldn't this be (currently) quite limited for "mind-reading" if it only picks up signals from reading and learns them. There is a difference between mapping "inner voice" and whatever is read.

Granted there may be chains of assumptions of advancement involved between them into actual thought-reading, but we've seen before how the devil has hid in those details in advancement chains. See all of the problems with autonomous vehicles in practice. People kind of suck at predicting what problems will be easy to solve.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#173

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well you are going to have a brain scanning device directly linked to your social credit score. That's the future.

Why are you so certain that’s the future?

Because spouting FUD is easier than actually doing anything.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#174

> While it’s not the first technology to be able to translate brain signals into language, it’s the only one so far to require neither brain implants nor access to a full-on MRI machine. I wonder whether, in a decade or two, if the sensor technology has gotten good enough that they don't even need you to wear a cap, just there'll be people saying "obviously you don't have any reasonable expectation of not having your…

We are still operating computers the same way we did in the 1970s: keyboards and screens. I'm not holding my breath.

No we are not. Voice and touchscreens now for much computer usage.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#175
post #53

Everyone is this thread immediately went to mind readers as interrogation. But what about introspection? Many forms of teaching and therapy exist because we are incapable of self analyzing in a completely objective way. Being able to analyze your thought patterns outside your own head could lead to all sorts of improvements. You could find which teaching techniques are actually the most effective. You could objective…

> Being able to analyze your thought patterns outside your own head could lead to all sorts of improvements. Typing in a journal text file for 15 minutes every morning is already a thing... and it's free.

Yes, but it could be expensive.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#177
post #161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Urgh. And it gets worse from there. The bugs list on the repo has a closed and locked bug report from someone claiming that their code is using teacher forcing! https://github.com/duanyiqun/DeWave/issues/1 In a normal recurrent neural network, the model predicts token-at-a-time. It predicts a token, and that token is appended to the total prediction so far which is then fed back into the model to generate the next to…

how could such thing get published?

My guess is repeatability is hard when it comes to AI

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#178

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We are still operating computers the same way we did in the 1970s: keyboards and screens. I'm not holding my breath.

No we are not. Voice and touchscreens now for much computer usage.

Touchscreens are effectively keyboards, just glossy flat ones.

Voice works as a very inferior substitute when hands-free operation is of overriding importance.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#179

I did a PhD in brain-computer interfaces, including EEG and implanted electrodes. BCI research to a big extent focuses on helping paralyzed individuals regain communication. Unfortunately, EEG doesn’t provide sufficient signal-to-noise ratio to support good communication speeds outside of the lab with Faraday cages and days/weeks of de-noising including removing eye-movement artifacts in the recordings. This is a phy…

What’s your thoughts of Elon’s NeuraLink? Also, do you have an opinion on whether good AI algorithms (like in the article) can help filter out or parse a lot of the noise?

In my understanding, NeuraLink is just a research project thaf musk invested into and did some PR for. I wouldn't read into it more than that. Like any other similar BCI research project feel free to ignore it until papers are published. That is, unless you are involved in the field.
Post reply on HN