Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

iflscience.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

71–80 of 208 posts

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#71

Post by ctoth »

ctoth wrote: post #64
digdigdag wrote: post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why not? There are perfectly legitimate uses for this kind of technology. This would be a godsend for those suffering from paralysis and nervous system disorders, allowing them to communicate with their loved ones. Yes, the CIA, DARPA, et. al. will be all over this (surprisingly if not already), but this is a sacrifice worth making for this kind of technology.

How many people in the whole world are paralyzed or locked in? Ten thousand? Less? How many people in the whole world are tinpot authoritarian despots just looking for an excuse who would just love to be able to look inside your mind? Somehow, I imagine the first number is dramatically dwarfed by the second number. This is a technology that, once it is invented, will find more and more and more and more uses. We need…

The other thing you people are missing is how technology compounds. You don't need to have people come in to the police station to have their thoughts reviewed when everyone is assigned an LLM at birth to watch over their thoughts in loving grace and maybe play a sound when they have the wrong one.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#72

Post by blindriver »

MoSattler wrote: post #35
varispeed wrote: post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well you are going to have a brain scanning device directly linked to your social credit score. That's the future.

First use will be for criminal suspects, to "save lives". Then its use slowly expands from there.

"For the children" is the first excuse usually.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#74

Post by swayvil »

Sanzig wrote: post #16
admax88qqq wrote: post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Combine hallucinations with police adopting this as the new polygraph and this could take a pretty bad turn. Cool tech though, lots of positive applications too.

If noninvasive mind reading ever becomes practical, we need to recognize the right to refuse a brain scan a universal human right. Additionally, it should be banned from being used for evidence in the courtroom. Unfortunately there will be authoritarian regimes that will use and abuse this type of tech, but we need to take a firm stand against it in liberal democracies at the very least.

What if it went the opposite way?

What if perfect brainreaders/liedetectors became as common as smartphones.

Used on everybody all the time. From politicians and cops to schoolkids and your own siblings.

What would be an optimistic version of that?

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#75

Post by exabyte »

notfed wrote: post #56
ctoth wrote: post #28

"Seriously, what were these researchers thinking? This 'BrainGPT' thing is a disaster waiting to happen. Ching-Ten Lin and his team of potential civilization destroyers at the University of Technology Sydney might be patting themselves on the back for this, but did they stop to think about the real-world implications? We're talking about reading thoughts—this isn't sci-fi, it's real, and it's terrifying. Where's the…

I'm optimistically going to assume that model training is per-brain, and can't cross over to other brains. Am I wrong? God I hope I'm not wrong.

My intuition is at least in the beginning, but with enough individual data won't you have a model that can generalize pretty well over similar cultures? Maybe moreso for the sheep, just speculating... who knows!

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#76

Post by ulf-77723 »

ctoth wrote: post #28

"Seriously, what were these researchers thinking? This 'BrainGPT' thing is a disaster waiting to happen. Ching-Ten Lin and his team of potential civilization destroyers at the University of Technology Sydney might be patting themselves on the back for this, but did they stop to think about the real-world implications? We're talking about reading thoughts—this isn't sci-fi, it's real, and it's terrifying. Where's the…

Exactly. Dangerous technology. Reminds me of dystopian sci-fi like inception or minority report.

First thing that came to my mind was an airport check. “Oh, you want to enter this country? Just use this device for a few minutes, please”

How about courts and testimony?

This tech will be used against you faster than you will recognize. Later on one will ask, why people let it happen.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#77

Post by e2le »

MoSattler wrote: post #35
varispeed wrote: post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well you are going to have a brain scanning device directly linked to your social credit score. That's the future.

First use will be for criminal suspects, to "save lives". Then its use slowly expands from there.

I'm sure among the first applications of this technology will be to scan user thoughts for evidence of CSAM.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#78

Post by alentred »

ctoth wrote: post #28

"Seriously, what were these researchers thinking? This 'BrainGPT' thing is a disaster waiting to happen. Ching-Ten Lin and his team of potential civilization destroyers at the University of Technology Sydney might be patting themselves on the back for this, but did they stop to think about the real-world implications? We're talking about reading thoughts—this isn't sci-fi, it's real, and it's terrifying. Where's the…

What is the alternative? Hide the research papers in a cabinet and never talk about it? How long would it be before another team achieves the same result? Trying to keep it under wraps would only increase the chance of this technology being abused, but now unbeknownst to the general public.

Basically, are you proposing to ban some fields of research because the result can be abused? Anything can be abused. From the social care system to scientific breakthroughs. What the society should do is to control the abuse, not stop the progress. Not even because of ethics, where the opinions diverge, but because stopping the progress is virtually impossible.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#79

Post by Y_Y »

derefr wrote: post #54
rvnx wrote: post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree sadly :( You're right, this is why in year 2200, your job application is going to be fast-tracked by analyzing your thoughts directly. If you have a Neuralink, no problems, you can directly upload a trace of thoughts. In case you have wrong thoughts, don't worry, we have rehabilitation school, which can alter your state of mind. Don't forget to be happy, it's forbidden to be sad. Also, this is read-only for n…

> If you have a Neuralink, no problems, you can directly upload a trace of thoughts. Except that someone with a jailbroken Neuralink could upload a filtered and arbitrarily-modified thought trace, getting ahead of all those plebs. Cyberpunk! :)

Just think a virus, you know they're not going to be correctly sanitizing their inputs.

Re: BrainGPT turns thoughts into text

#80

Post by [deleted] »

ctoth wrote: post #28

"Seriously, what were these researchers thinking? This 'BrainGPT' thing is a disaster waiting to happen. Ching-Ten Lin and his team of potential civilization destroyers at the University of Technology Sydney might be patting themselves on the back for this, but did they stop to think about the real-world implications? We're talking about reading thoughts—this isn't sci-fi, it's real, and it's terrifying. Where's the…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN