Live data from Hacker News

The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

crowdsupply.com

41–50 of 97 posts

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#41

Looks like 3 iPods stacked on top of one another.

More like 1 iPod? https://apple.fandom.com/wiki/IPod_(1st_generation)

Which had a hard drive. The last gen classic is much thinner (and probably had better battery life than the Tangara). It’s hard to understand why does it have to be so bulky but I assume it’s intentional (e.g. full size SD slot).

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#42

Non rockbox, non easily swappable battery (though it uses a rectangular cell with a JST connector), looks like an early ipod, no speaker(?), costs $249? Um no. There are still plenty of Sandisk and other players around that can run Rockbox. I still have a Cowon D2 that had a Rockbox port that apparently wasn't really complete. Its main drawback as I saw it was not supporting SDXC (i.e. largest supported SD card was 3…

> Non rockbox, non easily swappable battery (though it uses a rectangular cell with a JST connector), looks like an early ipod, no speaker(?), costs $249? Um no.

> No wireless. Less space than a Nomad. Lame.

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I still use my Sanclip Plus because of rockbox. What a great project

How come it haven't died still? They're are notorious for their internal memory crapping out.

Honestly, I use it only on big road trips I take a couple of times a year -- so it's not constant use, though it is regular use.

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#44

Non rockbox, non easily swappable battery (though it uses a rectangular cell with a JST connector), looks like an early ipod, no speaker(?), costs $249? Um no. There are still plenty of Sandisk and other players around that can run Rockbox. I still have a Cowon D2 that had a Rockbox port that apparently wasn't really complete. Its main drawback as I saw it was not supporting SDXC (i.e. largest supported SD card was 3…

[deleted]

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#46

This looks promising. Pretty much all modern portable music players are janky Android devices with awful hardware and software. I've been looking for something to dethrone the Zune HD for me, which has a small form factor and intuitive interface

I still have mine but left it in a drawer years ago because it wouldn't sync any more. Is there a modern solution?

They still sell the iPod touch

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#47
post #36

I get over 2+ weeks of playback time on my modded iPod classic with Rockbox and a half tb of storage. That’s the player I wish I had in the 200s.

I tested mine and it came out to around 65hrs w/ rockbox playing FLACs.

I've also got a Sansa Clip+ that is super small and great with Rockbox.

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#48
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some older portable media players are supported by Rockbox, which supports Opus. Unclear if there's any supported devices currently in production. As for SD cards, I know SanDisk devices on that list supported microSD cards. https://www.rockbox.org/

The downside is that most older players can decode MP3 and AAC in hardware but Opus has to be done in the CPU, which causes a big hit on battery life.

I had this experience when running RockBox on an iPod to play OGG files. The battery was much shorter.

I can't remember how battery life compared for MP3/AAC (was RockBox able to use the hardware decoder?).

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#49
post #24

Why does it have no buttons? There are plenty of good rockbox able MP3 players on the market. What I need is buttons with feedback.

The cool thing about mp3 players and phones with physical buttons is you could control them in your pocket with one hand while riding a bcycle to school. I remember texting someone on a T9 numpad, once you got the hang of it you could do it with the phone behind your back!

Later I had the worst designed mp3 player created by man which despite having physical buttons, still required you to look at the screen to use it because button presses were (a) context specific (required sequences) and (b) not idempotent (the first press was ignored and brought the device out of sleep mode).

Re: The music player you wish you had in the early 2000s

#50

This looks promising. Pretty much all modern portable music players are janky Android devices with awful hardware and software. I've been looking for something to dethrone the Zune HD for me, which has a small form factor and intuitive interface

I still have mine but left it in a drawer years ago because it wouldn't sync any more. Is there a modern solution?

I use GMTP to put files onto the device on Linux
Post reply on HN