Live data from Hacker News

Proton Mail gets a desktop app for encrypted email and calendar

theverge.com

21–30 of 100 posts

Re: Proton Mail gets a desktop app for encrypted email and calendar

#21
post #8

Out of curiosity, what makes people prefer desktop apps for mail over just visiting the browser version? The idea of downloading a desktop app for something I can do in the browser makes no sense to me. At least on mobile, the ergonomics of apps tend to make the experience better than the mobile-web version.

Less tab clutter, enhanced ability to use OS app/window management facilities, no space eating browser chrome, works without a browser being open (yes that does happen on occasion).

It doesn’t apply to Proton’s desktop app specifically but generic email clients also allow management of multiple accounts in a single window without the messiness of forwarding.

Re: Proton Mail gets a desktop app for encrypted email and calendar

#22
post #13
post #2

Let's hope it's not just another Electron-based abomination.

That ship has sailed. If I look at my Dock right now, from left to right I'm running: - Nautilus - Brave (Chromium) - Gnome-terminal - VSCode (Electron) - Telegram Desktop (̶E̶l̶e̶c̶t̶r̶o̶n̶ QT)[1] - WhatsApp (web wrapper in Electron)[1] - Discord (Electron) - Spotify (Chromium Embedded Framework) - Betterbird (Gecko, might as well be Electron) - TickTick (Electron) - Steam (Chromium Embedded Framework) In a way it i…

Telegram Desktop is fortunately not an electron app. It's Qt.

Re: Proton Mail gets a desktop app for encrypted email and calendar

#23
post #15
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Webmail requires an active Internet connection. A desktop client lets me work in more environments/situations, and acts as a kind of local backup/cache of my communications. It also makes focusing on email easier. I dislike having to dive into tab sprawl to read/write email.

webmail works fine without an internet connection, gmail does it. You need to write a PWA.

But do I have a local backup if my webmail provider deletes my account?

Re: Proton Mail gets a desktop app for encrypted email and calendar

#25
post #13
post #2

Let's hope it's not just another Electron-based abomination.

That ship has sailed. If I look at my Dock right now, from left to right I'm running: - Nautilus - Brave (Chromium) - Gnome-terminal - VSCode (Electron) - Telegram Desktop (̶E̶l̶e̶c̶t̶r̶o̶n̶ QT)[1] - WhatsApp (web wrapper in Electron)[1] - Discord (Electron) - Spotify (Chromium Embedded Framework) - Betterbird (Gecko, might as well be Electron) - TickTick (Electron) - Steam (Chromium Embedded Framework) In a way it i…

How is telegram Electron if it's https://github.com/telegramdesktop/tdesktop C++/QT?

Re: Proton Mail gets a desktop app for encrypted email and calendar

#26
post #23
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

webmail works fine without an internet connection, gmail does it. You need to write a PWA.

But do I have a local backup if my webmail provider deletes my account?

https://proton.me/support/export-emails-import-export-app

Re: Proton Mail gets a desktop app for encrypted email and calendar

#28
post #13
post #2

Let's hope it's not just another Electron-based abomination.

That ship has sailed. If I look at my Dock right now, from left to right I'm running: - Nautilus - Brave (Chromium) - Gnome-terminal - VSCode (Electron) - Telegram Desktop (̶E̶l̶e̶c̶t̶r̶o̶n̶ QT)[1] - WhatsApp (web wrapper in Electron)[1] - Discord (Electron) - Spotify (Chromium Embedded Framework) - Betterbird (Gecko, might as well be Electron) - TickTick (Electron) - Steam (Chromium Embedded Framework) In a way it i…

The official Telegram client is Qt on Windows and Linux and AppKit on macOS, not Electron.

Re: Proton Mail gets a desktop app for encrypted email and calendar

#29
post #22
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That ship has sailed. If I look at my Dock right now, from left to right I'm running: - Nautilus - Brave (Chromium) - Gnome-terminal - VSCode (Electron) - Telegram Desktop (̶E̶l̶e̶c̶t̶r̶o̶n̶ QT)[1] - WhatsApp (web wrapper in Electron)[1] - Discord (Electron) - Spotify (Chromium Embedded Framework) - Betterbird (Gecko, might as well be Electron) - TickTick (Electron) - Steam (Chromium Embedded Framework) In a way it i…

Telegram Desktop is fortunately not an electron app. It's Qt.

Thanks, edited!

I must admit it / its performance feels very "webby"

Post reply on HN