Live data from Hacker News

A study of Google's code review tooling (Critique)

engineercodex.substack.com

301–302 of 302 posts

Re: A study of Google's code review tooling (Critique)

#302

Shameless plug - I'm one of the creators of GitContext ( https://gitcontext.com ), a code review tool which has drawn much inspiration from Critique and others, and would love feedback from anyone who's interested in kicking the tires. We just launched in private alpha. We're putting a maniacal focus into the user experience of code reviews, which we feel is overlooked by most tools. Many of the features of Critique…

Am I missing some of the features? The GUI does seem to be nicer, but functionally all I see thats added is support for non-blocking comments and explicit opt out of parts of the review. Maybe the visibility of what reviewers have already completed as well?

The "pick up where you left off" is already available but requires you to manually indicate file-by-file when you've completed your review. The personal Todo list is also very present.

What am I missing?

Post reply on HN