Live data from Hacker News

Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

theguardian.com

131–140 of 203 posts

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#131
post #111
post #46

As always, these sales happen on a predetermined schedule for executives. This has nothing to do with the layoffs.

Yes, so if he sells regularly and is in charge of decisions that affect the price - what difference does your justification make?

He is not omniscient. He doesn't know what effect layoffs will have on stock price.

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#132
post #39

It’s kind of weird to see people want to work at big corporations but then act surprised or salty about layoffs. It’s nothing personal. You’re a line number even if you’re some leet coder. It’s a business, and it’s a strategy game of utilizing resources. You might have 400k TC but you’re not god you’re a resource. If you think these things aren’t fair or suck, then you should try to move out of the leet coder path an…

It's really funny to see hackers fall in line to work at big companies. In the 90s all the true hackers hated large established companies and would show them the finger and work for scrappy upstarts. And now all the kids are bending over backwards to work for these large corporations doing hours of leetcode. What a shame.

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#133
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It should actually be very very expensive for a company to fire people. Why do stock markets have an automated forced "PAUSE" when stocks seem like they are crashing? It's because companies, investors, people, or even computers don't always act rationally. That pause has prevented a lot of hiccups from turning into full-blown crashes. Right now, when a company lays people off, the town, state, and federal government…

> when a company lays people off, the town, state, and federal government are the ones who have to end up picking up the downstream effects If the existing unemployment _insurance_ (forced payroll contributions to each State) are not sufficient, then change that insurance system. There could be a business opportunity for supplemental market-priced contributions which pay on job loss. That wouldn't be worse than the '…

> There could be a business opportunity for supplemental market-priced contributions which pay on job loss.

Private job loss insurance exists already, its not an non-addressed potential market.

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#134
post #90
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> He can sell his shares when he feels like it He, in fact, cannot. As a C level executive he is going to trade on a 10b5-1 schedule.

Thanks for the insightful comment. I guess they can still conveniently schedule when the layoffs are announced and make it happen right before the 10b5-1 schedule? All the previous layoffs announcements were followed by the stock rising up.

> I guess they can still conveniently schedule when the layoffs are announced and make it happen right before the 10b5-1 schedule?

This is still a gamble at best. Let's not go down a conspiracy rabbit hole here.

CEOs have their trading schedules set well in advance, they do not know how the market will respond to their actions ahead of time. They can at best make an educated guess.

But the idea that he scheduled this layoff specifically for personal gain is pretty unfounded.

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#135
post #39

It’s kind of weird to see people want to work at big corporations but then act surprised or salty about layoffs. It’s nothing personal. You’re a line number even if you’re some leet coder. It’s a business, and it’s a strategy game of utilizing resources. You might have 400k TC but you’re not god you’re a resource. If you think these things aren’t fair or suck, then you should try to move out of the leet coder path an…

It's really funny to see hackers fall in line to work at big companies. In the 90s all the true hackers hated large established companies and would show them the finger and work for scrappy upstarts. And now all the kids are bending over backwards to work for these large corporations doing hours of leetcode. What a shame.

It's almost as if when kids grow up and have kids of their own, and have bills to pay, they hold their nose and do things they don't really want to do. of course, some of us never grow up and live in hippie communes and eschew the trappings of things like money.

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#136
post #30

Isn't this considered insider trading? You'd think there should be a blackout period around any kind of layoff, similar to how they do with earnings.

How is it insider trading? He sold the stock after the material became public knowledge. He didn't have any insider information

>He sold the stock after the material became public knowledge.

Are there rules about how long you need to wait after the news goes public to sell? Otherwise, it still seems kind of unfair because you could sell 100 milliseconds later before the market can react.

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#137
post #98
post #66

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If you think these things aren’t fair or suck, then you should try to move out of the leet coder path and get on the capital owner or business operator side. You could also try to improve society. People don’t have to just take it, they can fight back. All power comes from the consent of the masses, none of these guys have the physical power to compel any of us to do anything at all, including let them live. Look w…

Why don’t you try to change society then? Honest question why do people always want someone else to do it? Go start a business with your friends who think same way. See if you can build a business that can take care of its employees and do something good. You could change your own life and that of your colleagues. Never go public, and you don’t have any pressure to grow at all costs. Don’t take on debt. Oh right. It’…

It's only hard to start a business if you are poor...

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#138
post #36

Spotify is a for-profit enterprise and if laying people off is the right financial choice then he's doing his job well. He can sell his shares when he feels like it.

Our society is inches away from extreme violence at all times and the relative peace and legitimacy of that society depends on securing broad consensus and consent of the governed and a reasonable distribution of resources. He can be killed and eaten for his protein content when someone feels like it too.

Well, as a member of society, my vote goes to the market over, you know, cannibalism. Pretty sure that vote isn’t hanging in the balance of the Spotify CFO.

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#139

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I told the CISO he was an idiot who didn't understand security (in front of many peers), because we disagreed on implementation. Soon after I was fired for "violating company policy". I realized being right is not the most important thing in the world, certainly not more important than being employed. The other lesson was to never involve myself in office politics again: it is irrelevant and ultimately lowers your st…

Another lesson you missed: don't be disrespectful to coworkers, including bosses. You are not entitled to offending people in a work environment.

Just because he/she didn't explicitly type it doesn't mean they missed the lesson.

Re: Spotify CFO cashes in £7.2M in shares after value surges on news of job cuts

#140

[flagged]

I think it's reasonable for people to be frustrated that laying people off (lost value/income/security for many) consistently translates into big payoffs (more money) for fewer others (CEOs, shareholders). It feels like a moral inversion.

Of course it’s reasonable - they wouldn’t play on your emotions and outrage otherwise.

That isn’t newsworthy. And this isn’t the place to vent about a “moral inversion.” Make a new forum where you have 2 minutes of hate every day and eventually you’ll realize how programmed you are to be frustrated at things you have no power over and how much of a rage-cycle the so called “news” industry have put you in.

Post reply on HN